The reply of SCHROETER (1795) is temperate and just. It does him honor, and he generously gives full justice to his critic.
It would hardly be worth while to mention this slight incident if it were not that during these years there certainly existed a feeling that HERSCHEL undervalued the labors of his cotemporaries.
This impression was fostered no doubt by his general habit of not quoting previous authorities in the fields which he was working.
A careful reading of his papers will, I think, show that his definite indebtedness to his _cotemporaries_ was vanishingly small. The work of MICHELL and WILSON he alludes to again and again, and always with appreciation. Certainly he seems to show a vein of annoyance that the papers of CHRISTIAN MAYER, _De novis in coelo sidereo phænomenis_ (1779), and _Beobachtungen von Fixsterntrabanten_ (1778), should have been quoted to prove that the method proposed by HERSCHEL in 1782 for ascertaining the parallax of the fixed stars by means of observations of those which were double, was not entirely original with himself.
There is direct proof that it was so,[22] and if this was not forthcoming it would be unnecessary, as he has amply shown in his Catalogue of Double Stars. One is reminded of his remarks on the use of the high magnifying powers by the impatience of his comments.
His proposal to call the newly discovered minor planets _asteroids_ (1802) was received as a sign that he wished to discriminate between the discoveries of PIAZZI and OLBERS and his own discovery of URANUS.[23]
He takes pains to quietly put this on one side in one of his papers, showing that he was cognizant of the existence of such a feeling.
I am tempted to resurrect from a deserved obscurity a notice of HERSCHEL'S _Observations on the Two Lately Discovered Celestial Bodies_ (_Philosophical Transactions_, 1802), printed in the first volume of the _Edinburgh Review_, simply to show the kind of envy to which even he, the glory of England, was subject.
The reviewer sets forth the principal results of HERSCHEL'S observations, and, after quoting his definition of the new term asteroid, goes on to say:
"If a new name must be found, why not call them by some appellation which shall, in some degree, be descriptive of, or at least consistent with, their properties? Why not, for instance, call them _Concentric Comets_, or _Planetary Comets_, or _Cometary Planets_? or, if a single term must be found, why may we not coin such a phrase as _Planetoid_ or _Cometoid_?"