[Footnote 668: But, on the other hand, marriage with a husband's brother or nephew is not expressly prohibited; _cf._ 5 _Mass. Hist. Coll._, V, 407, note.]

[Footnote 669: _Acts and Resolves_, I, 209; also _Charters and General Laws of Mass._, 283. GODDARD, _Mem. Hist. Bost._, II, 415 n. 2, is plainly in error when he says that this act "suggested the leading incident of HAWTHORNE'S _Scarlet Letter_." It probably originated in the similar law, already mentioned, for the punishment of adultery which is expressed in nearly the same words: see _Acts and Resolves_, I, 171.]

A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Volume 2 (of 3) — Part 189

[Footnote 670: 5 _Mass. Hist. Coll._, V, 407 n. 1.]

A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Volume 2 (of 3) — Part 189

The colonial laws on this subject were not allowed to slumber. From the records of the Connecticut court of assistants, for instance, it appears that in May, 1694, Nathaniel Finch is complained of "for that he hath unlawfully married to Elizabeth Hemmeway," sister "of the said Finch his first wife." The pleas of Finch's attorney are "esteemed to be insufficient, and also of an offensive nature." Accordingly, having considered all the facts of the case, the "rules of God's word, the judgment of most able Divines, and the Laws of this colony," the court finds the "said marriage to be incestuous and unlawful," and therefore declares it "to be wholly null and void;" further relegating the case to the county court to be held at New Haven the next June, "to lay such punishment on the said Finch for his said offence as the nature thereof doth require."[671]

A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Volume 2 (of 3) — Part 189

[Footnote 671: _Historical Magazine and Notes and Queries_, II, 301.]

While the Massachusetts act of 1695 does not expressly prohibit a woman from wedding her husband's brother, a passage in Sewall's _Diary_ shows that such unions were already treated as unlawful. On December 25, 1691, he writes, the "marriage of Hana Owen with her Husband's brother, is declar'd null by the court of Assistants. She commanded not to entertain him; enjoin'd to make a confession at Braintrey before the Congregation on Lecture Day, or Sabbath, pay fees of court and prison," and "to be dismissed."[672]

[Footnote 672: SEWALL'S _Diary_, in 5 _Mass. Hist. Coll._, V, 354. For the case see NOBLE'S _Recs. of the Court of Assistants_, I, 361. Samuel Newton, of Marlborough, married his uncle's widow and had two children by her. This marriage was judged void "by the word of God, as also by the law of England": _ibid._, 342. _Cf._ COWLEY, _Our Divorce Courts_, 30, 31.]