The National Health Insurance Bill is a bill passed by the National Assembly of South Africa on 13 June 2023. The Bill contemplates the establishment of a South African national health insurance system, commonly referred to as NHI, with the aim of "pooling public revenue in order to actively and strategically purchase health care services" and creating a "single framework throughout the Republic for the public funding and public purchasing of health care services, medicines, health goods and health related products".
The purpose of the Bill is to establish and maintain a National Health Insurance Fund that will serve as the "single purchaser and single payer" of health care services.
Background
The South African healthcare system consists of a public and private sector, both of which are regulated to varying degrees by the Department of Health. The public healthcare system is utilised by approximately 84% of the South African population, and services are provided in accordance with a system of means testing. The private healthcare system primarily services members of medical schemes, which are voluntary health insurance providers that finance access, by approximately 16% of the population, to for-profit hospitals and primary healthcare facilities. This bifurcated system is characterised by inequalities in access to and quality of healthcare services — with the public sector being severely overburdened, under-resourced and mismanaged — which the Bill aims to address.
History
Early initiatives and contextual background
National Health Insurance in the South African context was first referenced by the Pienaar Commission, which was appointed in 1926 to consider the implementation of a system of social insurance. The commission's recommendations, which included a system of national health insurance for formally employed persons, were not immediately adopted, due in part to the influence of the subsequently constituted Carnegie Poor White Commission. The Pienaar Commission's findings ultimately resulted in the expansion of the social welfare programme of the South African government throughout the 1930s. The Public Health Department established a Committee of Inquiry into NHI in 1935, which advocated for social insurance for employees in urban areas who earned below a specified threshold, to be provided on a non-racial basis.
The early 1940s saw sustained interest in the development of the South African welfare state, amidst the release of the Beveridge Report in the United Kingdom and calls from medical associations to establish a national health system. A 1944 report by the National Health Services Commission recommended the creation of a needs-based, state-administered health service. Despite the appointment of liberal United Party parliamentarian Henry Gluckman as Minister of Health in 1945, prospects of establishing a national health service waned during the post-war period, particularly following the victory of the National Party in the 1948 general election.
The early healthcare policy of the National Party was characterised by increased regulation of medical schemes and private hospitals, which serviced a majority of white South Africans by 1960, and affirmed the position that the state ought to be the primary provider of healthcare services. The call for universal free medical care featured prominently in the 1955 Freedom Charter adopted by the African National Congress, which would later come to power following the abolition of apartheid.
Budgetary constraints and the ascendancy of neoliberal economic policy led to significant deregulation of private healthcare in the 1980s, including the relaxation of licensing requirements for private hospitals, increased fees for paying patients in state hospitals, and the removal of racial restrictions on medical scheme membership. This resulted in rapid expansion of the private healthcare sector, coupled with increasing costs and widespread market fragmentation, which encouraged a proliferation of research and policy proposals on national health insurance that would later influence the policy objectives of the ANC.