When the work is successful, the mass discharged from the converters is a basic silicate of PbO, CaO, and oxides of other metals present, and nearly all the sulphates have disappeared. A large piece of yellow product (which was taken from a well-worked converter) contained only 1.1 per cent. of total sulphur.
It may be that calcium plumbate is formed and plays a part in these reactions; but its presence would be difficult to prove, and its formation and existence during these stages would not be easy to explain. Neither does it seem necessary, as the whole thing appears to be capable of explanation without it.
While the mixture in the converter is still dry and loose, energetic oxidation of the sulphides goes on, with the intervention of the CaSO₄ as a carrier. As soon as the heat rises sufficiently, fluxing commences in a given layer and sulphates are decomposed. The liberated sulphuric anhydride, at the locally high temperature and under the existing conditions, will act with the greatest possible vigor on the sulphides in the adjacent layers; these layers will then in their turn flux and act on those above them, till the whole charge is worked out. The column of ore is of considerable hight, requiring a blast of 1½ lb., or perhaps more, in the larger converters now used. This pressure of the oxidizing blast (and of the far more powerfully oxidizing sulphuric anhydride, continuously being liberated within the mass of ore, locally very hot) constitutes a totally different set of conditions from those obtained on the hearth of a furnace with the ore in thin layers, where it is neither so hot nor under any pressure. It is to these conditions, in which we have the continued intense action of red-hot sulphuric anhydride under a considerable pressure (together with the earlier action of the CaSO₄), that the remarkable efficiency of the process seems to me to be due.
In the Carmichael process, the preliminary roast is done away with, CaSO₄ being added directly instead of having to be formed during the operation from CaO and the oxidized sulphur of the ore. The charge in the converter has to be started by heat supplied to it, and the work then goes forward on the same lines as in the Huntington-Heberlein process, so that we may assume that the reactions are the same and come under the same explanation.