Those are the only arguments that I wish to present.
Mr. CHANEY. To what section of this bill do you now refer?
Mr. CUTTER. I am referring to the subsection of this same section on page 24--section 30.
Mr. CURRIER. No; the subdivision called "First."
Mr. CUTTER. I suggest this amendment to the clause reading, "When imported, not more than one copy at one time, for use and not for sale, under permission given by the proprietor of the American copyright."
I suggest leaving out the consent of the American copyright proprietor. That changes existing law only in these particulars: It allows the importation of only one copy instead of two copies, as the existing law does; it gives the importer who has established a business here based on legislation, and who is closely in touch--the firms that I speak of serve libraries and learned men mostly with expensive books and have practically no sale to the ordinary public--it would give them an opportunity, and it would give a scholar in this country who wants a book for a particular purpose for his own use and not for sale an opportunity to import it.
Mr. CHANEY. So that if you strike out "under permission given by the proprietor of the American copyright" it satisfies them?
Mr. CUTTER. It would satisfy the request of the importers, who are not publishers.
Mr. CURRIER. Do you appear for the importers?
Mr. CUTTER. I appear for one of them only.
The CHAIRMAN. Do you feel that you are authorized to speak for the others?
Mr. CUTTER. I am authorized to speak for one firm only.
The CHAIRMAN. Do you feel that you represent the other importing firms?
Mr. CUTTER. I do not; no. I am quite convinced that I would be allowed to represent them, but I have had no communication with them.
Mr. BONYNGE. But you think you state their views on the subject?
Mr. CHANEY. You spoke of "ancient history" back as far as 1901. Do you regard anything back behind that as ancient history?
Mr. CUTTER. No; but it is ancient history in the book business. That is when the publishers of this country discovered that the Carnegie gifts had made the library trade so large that they must do something to make some more money out of it.
Mr. PUTNAM. With your permission, Mr. Chairman, I would suggest that Mr. Bethune, representing certain of the reproducing interests particularly--I ought not to limit that by the word "reproducing," but who represented at the conference the Reproductive Arts Copyright League--should be heard.