People of the Philippines v. Santos, Ressa and Rappler (R-MNL-19-01141-CR), also known as the Maria Ressa cyberlibel case, is a high-profile criminal case in the Philippines, lodged against Maria Ressa, co-owner and CEO of Rappler Inc.. Accused of cyberlibel, Ressa was found guilty by a Manila Regional Trial Court on June 15, 2020.

The case centered on an article published on Rappler by Reynaldo Santos Jr. which accused the former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines of accepting favors from Filipino-Chinese businessman Wilfredo Keng. Santos, Ressa, and others were charged with cyberlibel retrospectively, as the article was originally published four months before the Cybercrime Prevention Act came into effect. Rappler Inc., as a corporation, was not found liable; Santos, however, as author, was. Ressa, in her capacity of Rappler's chief executive officer, was also found liable. By the time Santos was charged, he was no longer working as a journalist for Rappler.

People of the Philippines v. Santos, Ressa and Rappler

The court ruled that Ressa "did not offer a scintilla of proof that they verified the imputations of various crimes in the disputed article... [Rappler] just simply published them as news in their online publication in reckless disregard of whether they are false or not." The judgement also argued that Ressa had deliberately called herself an executive editor, rather than the editor-in-chief, in an attempt to avoid liability. Ressa, along with Santos Jr., appealed to the Court of Appeals after the conviction. However, the court upheld the decision, noting that the article is "defamatory or libelous per se"; a motion for reconsideration was denied by the appellate court, prompting Ressa to elevate the case to the Supreme Court for a judicial review.

People of the Philippines v. Santos, Ressa and Rappler

The ruling was criticized by several human rights groups and international organizations, with the United Nations High Commissioner of Human Rights describing the case as part of a "pattern of intimidation" against the Philippine press.

People of the Philippines v. Santos, Ressa and Rappler

Background

The Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 (R.A. 10175) was signed into law by President Benigno Aquino III on September 12, 2012, becoming effective on October 3. Among the actions criminalized by this law is "cyberlibel". Six days after the law commenced, the Supreme Court issued a temporary restraining order to stop its implementation. On February 18, 2014, the Court declared that the law is constitutional, upholding most of its provisions including cyberlibel.

Rappler is a Filipino news website that was co-founded in 2012 by journalist Maria Ressa. She served as the site's CEO and executive editor since its founding. On May 29, 2012, Rappler researcher and writer Reynaldo Santos Jr. published an article titled "CJ using SUVs of 'controversial' businessmen". Among those named in the article is businessman Wilfredo Keng. The article details Keng's involvement in a controversy surrounding Chief Justice Renato Corona, who was later impeached. , the article remains online.

Santos Jr.'s article primarily relied on a 2002 Philippine Star article as a source, as well as on an "intelligence report" prepared that same year by the National Security Council, which the article says implicated Keng in human trafficking and drug smuggling. This report, however, was not presented to the Court as evidence. On February 16, 2019, Philippine Star took down the aforementioned article after Keng threatened legal action.

On December 20, 2017, Keng filed a complaint-affidavit before the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) to charge Santos, Jr. and Ressa, along with Rappler's treasurer James Bitanga and six others, with cyberlibel. The NBI's Cybercrime Department argued that because of a legal gray area regarding the theory of "continuous publication", it can be assumed that Keng saw the article in question after the passing of the law. However, the NBI ultimately decided not to charge Rappler. The Department of Justice (DOJ) later took up the case and recommended the charges be filed. The DOJ reasoned that on February 19, 2014, the article was changed to correct a misspelling of the word "evasion", which can be considered as re-publication according to the department.