“It is only part of the great Riddle,” said the Earl, “why innocent beings _ever_ suffer. It _is_ a great strain on Faith—but not a _breaking_ strain, I think.”
“The sufferings of _horses_,” I said, “are chiefly caused by _Man’s_ cruelty. So _that_ is merely one of the many instances of Sin causing suffering to others than the Sinner himself. But don’t you find a _greater_ difficulty in sufferings inflicted by animals upon each other? For instance, a cat playing with a mouse. Assuming it to have no _moral_ responsibility, isn’t that a greater mystery than a man over-driving a horse?”
“I think it _is_,” said Lady Muriel, looking a mute appeal to her father.
“What right have we to make that assumption?” said the Earl. “_Many_ of our religious difficulties are merely deductions from unwarranted assumptions. The wisest answer to most of them, is, I think, ‘_behold, we know not anything_.’”
“You mentioned ‘division of labour,’ just now,” I said. “Surely it is carried to a wonderful perfection in a hive of bees?”
“So wonderful—so entirely super-human—” said the Earl, “and so entirely inconsistent with the intelligence they show in other ways—that I feel no doubt at all that it is _pure_ Instinct, and _not_, as some hold, a very high order of Reason. Look at the utter stupidity of a bee, trying to find its way out of an open window! It _doesn’t_ try, in any reasonable sense of the word: it simply bangs itself about! We should call a puppy _imbecile_, that behaved so. And yet we are asked to believe that its intellectual level is above Sir Isaac Newton!”
“Then you hold that _pure_ Instinct contains no _Reason_ at all?”
“On the contrary,” said the Earl, “I hold that the work of a bee-hive involves Reason of the _highest_ order. But none of it is done by the _Bee_. _God_ has reasoned it all out, and has put into the mind of the Bee the _conclusions_, only, of the reasoning process.”
“But how do their minds come to work _together_?” I asked.
“What right have we to assume that they _have_ minds?”
“Special pleading, special pleading!” Lady Muriel cried, in a most unfilial tone of triumph. “Why, you yourself said, just now, ‘the mind of the Bee’!”
“But I did _not_ say ‘_minds_,’ my child,” the Earl gently replied. “It has occurred to me, as the most probable solution of the ‘Bee’-mystery, that a swarm of Bees _have only one mind among them_. We often see one mind animating a most complex collection of limbs and organs, _when joined together_. How do we know that any material connection is necessary? May not mere neighbourhood be enough? If so, a swarm of bees is simply a single animal whose many limbs are not quite close together!”