Moscow Lomonosov State University, aerial view. Image by I.s.kopytov, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. This analysis article by Anna Rara-Avis appeared on OpenDemocracy on December 15, 2021. It is republished as part of a content-sharing partnership and has been edited to fit the GV style. In an attempt to improve the life of Russian universities, the government and the ministry of education are creating new projects and programmes, issuing more orders, introducing additional rules and releasing new grants. Just two or three more government decisions, it seems, and we will find ourselves on target: Russian universities and scientific institutions will break into the international rankings, and attract the world’s leading professors and students. But something is going wrong. Experts usually say that underfunding is the main problem for science and education in Russia. As UNESCO recently noted, the share of Russian state spending on science has declined in recent years: it was 1.07 percent of Russia’s GDP in 2014, but 0.99 percent in 2018. While there are plans to raise spending (to 1.2 percent of GDP by 2024), Russia’s state audit chamber notes that countries with developed scientific and technological capacities spend more than 3 percent. But there is another problem that is fundamentally hampering Russian science, and it is barely mentioned. A serious lack of freedom of speech hampers the work of Russian researchers and university staff. Polls asking whether people are afraid to express their opinion in public happen rarely in Russia. But in a country where hundreds are prosecuted every year for making political statements online or taking part in protests, such data can be illuminating. The last high-profile study on this topic was published in 2016 by the polling organisation Levada Center. A quarter of respondents (26 percent, of which 6 percent were ‘definite’) said they were afraid to express their views on the state of affairs in Russia in opinion polls, 23 percent in conversations with colleagues, and 17 percent with relatives and friends. The majority of respondents (56 percent) explained their wary attitude to polls by citing possible negative consequences for themselves. It’s difficult to say how this dynamic has changed as there has been no further research, but political scientist Margarita Zavadskaya has argued that “caution” is “the new norm of social behaviour” in Russian society. Russia’s so-called “syndrome of public silence” applies not only to the ‘average citizen’, but also to the country’s universities. Even staff who are supposed to communicate directly and openly with different audiences (for example, vice-rectors who need to work with students) prefer to minimise public discussions and not express their opinion. Yet teachers are silent not only in the classroom. They are also quiet in administration meetings, academic councils and surveys conducted by senior management – and even on social media. It is deemed appropriate to share information about your successes and achievements, but unacceptable to talk about problems or to criticise management decisions. To an extent, Russian academia’s public silence is the result of university regulations on the principles of professional conduct. These can restrict or shape comments made in public by employees (including on social media). Universities can write these regulations in different ways, but, in general, the main argument is that a university should focus on science and leave politics alone. Thus, the head of the Russian Presidential Human Rights Council, Valery Fadeev, believes that banning students and employees of Moscow’s Higher School of Economics from making public statements, including signing open letters, is not a restriction on freedom of speech. According to Fadeev, this ban is only “an attempt to minimise politicisation and attacks” on the university, which is ranked among the top 25 in the world, and has found itself at the centre of political scandals in recent years. However, these regulations are not always prohibitive. University staff often engage in self-censorship. In November, I surveyed members of a Facebook group dedicated to Russian higher education issues (with almost 10,000 members). I asked an open-ended question similar to the one that was asked by the Levada Center in 2016: “Do you think your colleagues, representatives of the field of science and education, are afraid to publicly express their views on the current situation in the country?” This is the answer that received the most ‘likes’: Definitely yes. You’re always looking over your shoulder when you write your opinion on a particular issue. It is not even discussed. It’s really scary to write and you can’t write the whole truth.