The Cleveland Cripple Survey or Survey of Cripples in Cleveland was a survey done in Cleveland, Ohio first published in 1918 report by the Welfare Federation of Cleveland entitled: "Education and Occupations of cripples Juvenile and Adults: A Survey of All Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, 1916". The two reporters/authors for this Survey and report were Lucy Wright and Amy M. Hamburger. This survey is often credited as being one of the first accurate disability censuses, that measured the social and economic conditions of individuals considered.

Purpose and context

Many reports regarding this survey state that the purpose of the survey was to reveal the needs, constraints, and general conditions of the disability community within Cleveland. It was also revealed that the basis of the survey, which began its works in 1915, was formulated around various questions, one of which was: "What, then does the cripple want?". From this question the two authors undertook this project with aspiration to not only discover the true nature and size of the problems disabled individuals within the community faced but also to create feasible community based plan that would: "promote the welfare of cripples".

Cleveland Cripple Survey

Within the survey, a "cripple" is defined "as a person whose muscular movements are so far restricted by congenital defect, results of disease or accidents as to affect his capacity for self-support.". Individuals classified as blind or with cardiac problem were excluded from this definition.

Cleveland Cripple Survey

The Cleveland area was chosen as the sample for this survey due to the fact that it provided a booming industrial community that was majorly affected by two historical events. The first event was the early implementations of Workmen's Compensation and Employer's Liability Act. Disabled workers during this time period often faced discrimination by employers that often feared that hiring disabled laborers would increase their insurance rates and increase their own liability for providing workers compensation benefits. The next historical event was the early spread of Poliomyelitis or the Polio Virus, which in densely populated cities such as Cleveland was rapidly infecting numerous laborers children, thus creating adding to the number of disabled individuals. Wounded Veterans returning from World War I also added to these newly classified disabled individuals. Because of this rapid increase of disabled individuals the survey uncovered over 60 percent of individuals they deemed disabled by their definition were in fact not documented as so by their local ordinances.

Cleveland Cripple Survey

Research methods

Common to the Progressive Era, Social Survey was used as the method to collect information. Work for the survey began on October 17, 1915, and was completed August 19, 1916 . Data for this survey was obtained by canvassing eight districts of the city with house-to house-visits, scheduled questions, and survey cards. The initial process began for the survey was done by amateur volunteer workers, students, and some experienced social workers that canvassed the eight districts with "lists of cripples" provided to them by hospitals, dispensaries and social agencies (24). A total of 150,000 families from all economic backgrounds were canvassed within the survey. Out of that number 4,186 were given survey cards that were compiled within a 12-month span. The estimated total cost for the survey was reported at $12,500 dollars.

Results

The survey uncovered a variety of findings from the series of questions that families were asked to answer on a survey card. These suggested that disabled individuals had discovered ways to stay economically successful despite societal constraints and lack of government assistance. In addition, the survey established a greater need for disabled child assistance programs and institutions. More dependent disabled children as well

The population and age demographics revealed that nearly half of the individuals that were classified as "crippled", became disabled before the age of 15. 43 percent became classified during active working years (ages 15–60) while only 6 percent became classified after age 60. Out of the 936 cases that identified as becoming disabled at childhood, 382 were attributed to the Polio Virus (Infantile Paralysis). These results confirmed the severity of virus's epidemic and suggested that preventive measure should be taken to limit the illness from spreading further.