SMITH--I was present when Mr. Goodere was brought to Bristol after this murder happened, when he was asked (before the justices) about the seizing, detaining and murdering sir John Dineley; and he then directly answered that he did not know that his brother was murdered or dead. He was then asked in relation to the manner of seizing him, and carrying him away; he said he knew nothing of it till he came to the boat, and when he came there he saw his brother in the boat; but he did not know that his brother had been used at that rate.
SHEPARD--Mr. Smith, Sir, you are speaking about sir John; by what name did you commonly call him?
THE RECORDER--Mr. Goodere, have you any questions to ask Mr. Smith?
GOODERE--Yes, Sir. Mr. Smith, I ask you what sir John Dineley's business was with you, and how much money were you to advance?
SMITH--Five thousand pounds, Sir; and I told him that I was satisfied that it was a good title.
GOODERE--I ask you if you knew him to be a knight and a baronet?
SMITH--I can't tell; I never saw the letters patent.
GOODERE--Can't you tell how you styled him in the writings?
_Vernon_ objected to this, because baronetage must be derived from letters-patent, and therefore could not be properly proved by Mr. Smith's personal knowledge; and added that it was not material, because the indictment alleged that the person murdered was Sir John Dineley Goodere, and the prosecution would prove that he usually went by that name.
To this _Shepard_ answered that if the person killed was a baronet, and was not so described, there was a misdescription, and the prisoners could not be convicted on that indictment.
_Vernon_ then argued at some length that the necessity of setting out a personal description in an indictment applied only to the defendant, and that all that the law required in the description of the person on whom the offence was committed was a convenient certainty; and that a description by the Christian and surname sufficed. Besides, this was all begging the question, for as it did not appear in proof that the deceased was a baronet, he might, for all that appeared judicially, have been christened Sir John.
Had we called the deceased in the indictment sir John Dineley Goodere baronet, then, Sir, we should probably have been told that we had failed in proof of the identity of the person, for that the baronetage was in its creation annexed to, and made a concomitant on, the patentee's name of Goodere, and waited only on that name; and that the deceased, considered as a baronet, was not of the maternal name of Dineley, and so upon the matter no such person as sir John Dineley Goodere baronet ever existed _in rerum natura_.[53]