.—. Theognostus; Dionysius of Alexandria; Dionysius of Rome; Origen.

25. then is the

sense in which they who met at Nicæa made use of these

expressions. But next that they did not invent them for themselves

(since this is one of their excuses), but spoke what they had received

from their predecessors, proceed we to prove this also, to cut off even

this excuse from them. Know then, O Arians, foes of Christ, that

Theognostus, a learned man, did not decline the

phrase ‘of the essence,’ for in the second book of his

Hypotyposes, he writes thus of the Son:—

“The essence of the Son is not one procured

from without, nor accruing out of

nothing, but it sprang from the Father’s

essence, as the radiance of light, as the vapour

of water; for neither the radiance, nor the vapour, is the water itself

or the sun itself, nor is it alien; but it is an effluence of the

Father’s essence, which, however, suffers no partition. For as

the sun remains the same, and is not impaired by the rays poured forth

by it, so neither does the Father’s essence suffer change, though

it has the Son as an Image of Itself.”

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume IV/Defence of the Nicene Definition/De Decretis/Chapter 6

Theognostus then, after previously investigating

in the way of an exercise, proceeds to lay down

his sentiments in the foregoing words. Next, Dionysius, who was Bishop

of Alexandria, upon his writing against Sabellius and expounding at

large the Saviour’s Economy according to the flesh, and thence

proving against the Sabellians that not the Father but His Word became

flesh, as John has said, was suspected of saying that the Son as a

thing made and originated, and not one in essence with the Father; on

this he writes to his namesake Dionysius, Bishop of Rome, to allege in

his defence that this was a slander upon him. And he assured him that

he had not called the Son made, nay, did confess Him to be even one in

essence. And his words ran thus:—

“And I have written in another letter a

refutation of the false charge they bring against me, that I deny that

Christ was one in essence with God. For though I say that I have not

found this term anywhere in Holy Scripture, yet my remarks which

follow, and which they have not noticed, are not inconsistent with that

belief. For I instanced human birth as being evidently homogeneous, and

I observed that undeniably parents differed from their children only in

not being the same individuals, otherwise there could be neither

parents nor children. And my letter, as I said before, owing to present

circumstances I am unable to produce; or I would have sent you the very

words I used, or rather a copy of it all, which, if I have an

opportunity, I will do still. But I am sure from recollection that I

adduced parallels of things kindred with each other; for instance, that

a plant grown from seed or from root, was other than that from which it

sprang, yet was altogether one in nature with it: and that a stream flowing from a fountain, gained a new name, for that neither the fountain was called stream, nor the stream fountain, and both existed, and the stream was the water from the fountain”

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume IV/Defence of the Nicene Definition/De Decretis/Chapter 6