In this edition of the court judgements review, we look into the Madras HC’s judgment that said any person belonging to any caste or creed can be appointed as an Archaka provided he is well-versed and properly trained to perform the rituals, Karnataka HC’s assertion that both giver and taker of corruption are susceptible to prosecution, Punjab HC’s comments that merely because a woman committed suicide in matrimonial home, doesn’t imply that the husband and in-laws harassed her, among others. Madras HC: Any person belonging to any caste or creed can be appointed as an Archaka provided he is well-versed and properly trained to perform the rituals The complainant in the case Muthu Subramania Gurukkal vs. the Commissioner, Hindu Religious & Charitable Endowment Department, and others had filed a petition before the Court in 2018 against the advertisement for the appointment to the position of Archakas/Sthanikam (or someone who performs rituals). He contended that the advertisement infringed upon his hereditary right to the position as it was his family belonging to a certain caste who occupied the position since time immemorial. He also contended that the Executive Officer could not appoint the priest referring to an order of the Madras High Court which held that a committee was to be appointed for identifying temples belonging to Agama and until then, the appointment cannot be made. As per the order, in Agamic temples, appointment to the position was to be done as per custom. Further, he also questioned the certificate courses recognised by the Department and submitted that the Agamas and Vedas cannot be learnt by undergoing a certificate course. Justice Anand Venkatesh of the Madras High Court observed that in temples governed by the Agama, the Trustees/Fit Person only must ensure that the Archaka/Sthanikam to be appointed is well-versed and properly trained to perform the pooja as per the Agama. He highlighted that the pedigree based on caste would have no role to play in the appointment if the person so selected otherwise satisfies the requirements. It was also noted that the division bench had not observed in the order that the Trustees or the Fit persons cannot make appointments till the committee finalizes the report. It also allowed the recruitment process to continue and stated that the petitioner can also apply for the same. Consumer Commission directs Bank to pay compensation for deficiency in service In Abha Dobriyal & Another vs. Bank of Baroda & HUDCO, the complainants were a couple who had taken a housing loan of Rs. 50 lakhs from the Bank of Baroda in October 2018. They did so to avail benefits of subsidy under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) scheme and submitted the necessary documents to the bank. Later, in August 2020, they received a message that an Application ID had been generated for PMAY (U). However, they did not get a response of any benefit from the bank despite sending multiple emails and reminders to the bank. The couple filed a case before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Chandigarh alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice on the part of the bank because of which they had to face financial loss, harassment, and mental agony. In its reply, the bank acknowledged the disbursal of the loan. But it submitted that the complainants had not approached the bank for the scheme. It added that the couple may have applied for the scheme online because of which the application number was generated. The bank also stated that they had no clue about the application made by the complainants under the scheme and so, there was no point in considering the mails. Housing and Urban Development Corporation Limited (HUDCO) stated that the bank had uploaded the complainant’s subsidy claim in July 2020. But the claim was rejected by the corporation’s portal due to the wrong instalment number and a mismatch of the cumulative loan disbursement with the loan disbursement submitted up to the previous instalment. Further, it was stated that the bank did not upload the revised forms. The Consumer Commission presided over by members, Surjeet Sharma and B M Sharma observed that HUDCO’s statement completely contradicted the bank’s contention that it was completely unaware of the application. It concluded that the bank’s service was deficient and directed the Bank of Baroda to pay Rs 1 lakh for the same along with the litigation cost. The Commission dismissed the complaint against HUDCO regarding the credit benefit or subsidy claim. Karnataka HC: Both giver and taker of corruption are susceptible to prosecution In Kailash S Raj & others vs.