The government on 5 July 2019 gazetted the Freedom of Information Bill, which seeks to repeal the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act (AIPPA) and to give effect to Section 62 of the Constitution which provides for the right to access to information as enshrined in the Declaration of Rights. The Freedom of Information Bill is one of three expected to come out of the repeal of AIPPA, along with the Protection of Personal Information Bill and Zimbabwe Media Commission Bill. But media watchdogs and legal experts have cried foul saying government is insincere and has missed a great opportunity to do authentic media reforms acceptable locally and globally. What does the bill set out to do? It sets out the procedure of access to information held by public institutions or information held by any person, which is necessary for the exercise or protection of a right. It sets out considerations for making available on a voluntary basis by entities, certain categories of information thereby removing the need for formal requests for such information. It sets out the scope of limitations on the right of access to information, the rights of third parties, the role of principal officers of entities and information officers in its implementation, procedures for internal and court appeals in respect to requests for access to information and the time limits within which these processes must be carried out. It sets out additional functions of the Human Rights Commission with respect to the right of access to information, which are to be exercised in the normal course of its role as the guardian of human rights. Part Two of the Bill which deals with providing access to information, bestows in Clause 4, a duty on entities to maintain the information of entities in a manner that facilitates the exercise of the right to access information. Clause 5 of the Bill requires public entities, public commercial entities and holders of statutory bodies to disclose information which is in the interest of the public accountability and in the interest of protection of a right. Clause 6 states that the Act will not apply to information from Cabinet and its committees, with respect to judicial functions. Part Three deals with the process of requesting for access to information. In the event the request relates to information necessary to safeguard the life or liberty of a person, the information officer’s determination whether to grant access must be made within 48 hours. The Bill also requires responsible persons to make annual reports to the Human Rights Commission on the number of requests received, granted, refused or appealed. Part Five of the Bill sets out various grounds upon which a request for access may be refused for the purpose of protecting other rights and interests, which may be superior to the right of access to information. Clause Six of the Bill repeals AIPPA (Chapter 10:27). Does the Bill go far enough? Media watchdog Misa-Zimbabwe in statement in response to the gazette Bill says the Bill doesn’t go far enough. Misa’s argument goes as follows: The Bill in its current state fails to give effect to either the letter or spirit of the right to access information found in Section 62 of the Constitution. The Bill is different from the draft version shared with and discussed by stakeholders during engagement meetings held by the Ministry of Information Media and Broadcasting Services in December 2018 and March 2019. “It is a total departure from most of the positions agreed upon between the ministry and media stakeholders,” Misa says. The gazetted Bill has similarities with the condemned and outgoing AIPPA unlike the all-stakeholders draft which closely resembled the African Union’s Model Law on Access to Information. Few of the recommendations submitted by civil society and other access to information activists were incorporated into the gazetted Bill. “This shatters government’s narrative that this Bill is the result of a valid, wide, and balanced consultative process.” Veritas – a watchdog that provides information on the work of the Courts, Parliament of Zimbabwe and the Laws of Zimbabwe – has accused government of behaving badly saying the gazetted Bill contains none of the contributions from media stakeholders and contains marked differences from ministerial draft Bill circulated previously. (http://veritaszim.net/node/3583) What other issues does the Bill raise? It puts in place voluntary mechanisms of disclosing data and information controlled by public institutions. Private institutions, on the other hand, have the discretion to voluntarily disclose any information within their control.