An over-vigorous, sappy growth, often the result of a wet, warm autumn or too rich a soil, is certainly detrimental to autumn colouring. _Rhus cotinoides_, an American Sumach, worth growing for the beauty of its colours in autumn, is one of the most unfailing in this matter. This is perhaps one of the loveliest of all autumn-tinted shrubs, and should be more planted. But young plants, put out in well-trenched, heavily-manured soil, will often fail to colour at all till they get older and less vigorous. The most beautifully coloured examples of this Sumach that we have seen grow in rather light sandy soil. We have frequently noticed, too, that various species of Vine (_Vitis_) when starved in pots will colour exquisitely, whilst others, planted out in the ordinary way, completely fail. We believe, therefore, when planting with a view to the production of autumnal colour, any great enrichment of the soil is neither necessary nor advisable, provided it is of moderate quality to start with.
In the following notes, brief mention is made of some of the best trees, shrubs, and climbers that colour in autumn:--
First among these are the American Red Oaks. Undoubtedly the best of these is a variety of _Quercus coccinea_ known as _splendens_ and _grayana_. This not only turns to a fine scarlet crimson, but it retains its foliage for some weeks after the colour has been acquired--sometimes almost up to Christmas. Other good Oaks, not so certain, however, as the preceding, are _Quercus marylandica_ (or _nigra_), _Q. heterophylla_, _Q. imbricaria_, and _Q. palustris_, all of which turn red. The Tupelo tree (_Nyssa sylvatica_) turns a fine burnished bronzy red. A tree remarkable for the size of its leaves, and especially for the rich golden yellow they put on in autumn, is _Carya tomentosa_, but, like most of the Hickories, it is scarcely known in gardens. _Carya sulcata_ is somewhat similar. The Common Elm is usually very beautiful in the soft yellow tints of its leaves in autumn, but another Elm of more distinct aspect is _Ulmus pumila_, a low tree whose small leaves are retained till late in the year, and turn golden yellow before they fall. _Liquidambar styraciflua_ has long been valued for its fading foliage of purple red, but not so well known is the lovely yellow of the Fern-like foliage of the Honey Locust (_Gleditschia triacanthos_). The Tulip tree (_Liriodendron_), the Nettle trees (_Celtis_), the _Zelkowas_, and several of the Birches turn yellow, one of the best of the Birches being _Betula corylifolia_, which turns a rich orange yellow.