“The ignited hydrogen gas in burning produced the light corresponding to the two bright bands in the red and green; the remaining bright lines were not, however, coincident with those of oxygen, as might have been expected. According to this theory, the burning hydrogen must have greatly increased the heat of the solid matter of the photosphere and brought it into a state of more intense incandescence and luminosity, which may explain how the formerly faint star could so suddenly assume such remarkable brilliance; the liberated hydrogen became exhausted, the flame gradually abated, and with the consequent cooling the photosphere became less vivid, and the star returned to its original condition.”
According to the other theory, advanced by Meyer and Klein, the blazing forth of this new star may have been occasioned by the violent precipitation of some great mass, perhaps a planet, upon a fixed star, “by which the momentum of the falling mass would be changed into molecular motion,” and result in the emission of light and heat.
“It might even be supposed that the new star, through its rapid motion, may have come in contact with one of the nebulæ which traverse in great numbers the realms of space in every direction, and which from their gaseous condition must possess a high temperature; such a collision would necessarily set the star in a blaze, and occasion the most vehement ignition of its hydrogen.”
If we regard these two theories in their more general aspect, considering one as the theory that the origin of disturbance was within the star, and the other as the theory that the origin of disturbance was outside the star, they seem to include all possible interpretations of the observed phenomena. But, as actually advanced, neither seems satisfactory. The sudden pouring forth of hydrogen from the interior, in quantities sufficient to explain the outburst, seems altogether improbable. On the other hand, as I have pointed out elsewhere, there are reasons for rejecting the theory that the cause of the heat which suddenly affected this star was either the downfall of a planet on the star or the collision of the star with a star-cloudlet or nebula, traversing space in one direction, while the star rushed onwards in another.