All is decidedly not well in Quebec society today. This is especially obvious when we focus on the question of intercultural relations between the dominant francophone culture and the anglophone and allophone minorities. Our recent poll for CBC suggests half of those in Quebec’s anglophone and allophone communities have considered leaving the province in the past year — incontrovertible evidence of eroding social cohesion between these communities. This poll features large and high-quality random samples of all of the key linguistic groups and it gives us the opportunity to assess real changes over the past year by asking the same questions in a semantically consistent fashion. The results have been questioned by such notable polling experts as Premier Pauline Marois and others in the current PQ government who are loathe to acknowledge a serious and growing problem with the way the minorities in Quebec feel. They’ve pointed to the fact that over half of anglophones have not “seriously considered” leaving in the past year as evidence that the problem is not a problem. More serious commentary came from Michel Paillé at the Huffington Post, who argues that the survey was “rigged” due to a disconnect between recent mobility patterns and the numbers who said they had considered leaving. In the two interviews that I gave on this question, I explicitly pointed out that the poll could not even remotely be considered an accurate gauge of exodus behaviour. This poll tapped feelings, not behaviour, and must be considered in light of the broader patterns from other related questions on the survey. Acknowledging that the study was never intended as a demographic prediction of actual mobility, we must consider the question of whether the surveys show us anything truly important and new about the state of relations between francophone Quebeckers and linguistic minorities. We also acknowledge that it would be most interesting to have similar comparative data for other provinces to assess whether these findings are unique to Quebec. In the absence of such broader comparative testing, we will hazard a reasonable guess that the sorts of findings uncovered here are largely unique to Quebec. They show a clear and disturbing level of alienation in anglophone and allophone communities. It’s also worth noting the degree to which these two minority communities are in lockstep in terms of their growing mistrust of the current PQ government. While 90 per cent of francophones reported feeling “welcome” in Quebec, a much smaller 56 per cent of anglophones share that sense of comfort. Similar jarring gaps occur across questions about whether respondents feel “integrated” or share values with most Quebeckers. The problems of disconnection are not only normative and societal; they extend to the sense of economic opportunity. Whereas most francophones are confident that they and their children can succeed in Quebec, this level of confidence drops to about half among anglophones and allophones. This suggests that the sources of alienation are not only sociological but linked to economic prospects. English and allophone minorities in Quebec are exhibiting an alarming and deepening disconnect from Quebec’s society, economy and politics. The problem is real and it’s getting worse. It seems clear that the catalyst which would trigger an anglophone/allophone exodus would be a successful PQ majority and an ensuing referendum. Forecasting the political arithmetic of a referendum with a significantly diminished anglophone and allophone population, it seems highly plausible that the razor thin ‘No’ victory of 1995 would be replaced with a ‘Yes’ vote. Only 16 per cent of anglophones and 21 per cent of allophones are not angry with the Parti Québécois government — that’s a far more negative result for the PQ than in last year’s survey. Similarly, 87 per cent do not trust the government. The highly visible secular charter is seen almost universally in linguistic minority communities as a threat to human rights. Of about nine indicators which were polled both this year and last year, none improved and many significantly worsened. So Quebec’s spotty record on intercultural relationships moved from poor to awful over the past year. Observers may question the legitimacy of the survey on the grounds that we have not yet seen a significant exodus from these diminished linguistic minorities, or that there are large portions of the population who express satisfaction and comfort. They may also ask how these indicators would look in other provinces. All valid questions — but if they’re being used to suggest that the survey is meaningless or even “rigged”, then those criticisms are disingenuous and ignore the 800-pound gorilla in the room.