CHAPTER XV

THE IMMEDIATE PREPARATIONS

WHEN Pius IX. had finally resolved on assembling a

Council he proceeded without delay to the necessary

preparations. These preparations may be classified as

twofold : those within the Roman Communion, and

those relating to other religious bodies.

I. The internal preparations were largely entrusted to

a Commission of Cardinals, selected for that purpose. The Cardinals reported to the Pope upon the follow- ing points.

Roman Catholic Opposition to Papal Infallibility

First came the important problem, to determine who

were qualified for membership in a Council of the

Church. The Episcopate, of course, without all doubt. But did this apply only to Bishops possessing diocesan jurisdiction, or did it include those who possessed no definite See? It was urged that the latter were just as really Bishops as the former, and that their omission might raise disputes on the Council's validity. It was accordingly decided that, with the Pope's approval, titular Bishops as well as diocesan were qualified for seats in the coming Assembly.

Roman Catholic Opposition to Papal Infallibility

The case of Abbots and generals of religious Orders

was considered next. If these did not possess episcopal

authority, they possessed at least a real, a semi-episcopal

jurisdiction; being themselves superiors over a consider-

able multitude, and also exempt from episcopal control.

Roman Catholic Opposition to Papal Infallibility

217

218 IMMEDIATE PREPARATIONS [CHAP.

This quasi-episcopal position was considered by the

Congregation to qualify them for admission to the

Vatican Council. These decisions were of great signi-

ficance, as they added, it is said, almost two hundred

votes. 1

Secondly, as to regulations for procedure, 2 the

Cardinals asserted that the Pope alone had the right

to introduce matters for discussion. Otherwise, argued

the Cardinals, the Council would become a constitu-

tional chamber. But a Council is only -summoned to

discuss what the Pope desires to have discussed; not to

introduce their individual conceptions of what ought to

be done. If any reminiscences of the principles of

Constance, Pisa, and Basle floated before the Cardinals'

memories; if any distant echo of their predecessors'

intention to reform the Church in its head and members

haunted them; it was instantly condemned by the

theory now introduced. By way of dispelling the

possible objection that the Pope might omit important

matters, the Cardinals observed that it is an unlikely

thing, that it must be left to Providence, and that you

cannot expect perfection in human affairs. Whatever, therefore, the Bishops desire to introduce for conciliar discussion, they must report it, not to the Council, but to the Pope or to his representative; and the Pope will determine whether its introduction is desirable or not. The Cardinals recommend that a Commission should be created for this purpose.

In the third place, it was thought desirable that four

permanent Commissions should be formed : one on

faith; one on discipline; one on religious orders; one on missions. It was suggested that two -thirds of the members should be chosen by the Bishops and one-third by the Pope. Pius, however, decided

1 Friedrich, Dollinger, iii. p. 2o6ff. 2 Cecconi, i. p. 165.

xv.] PAPAL LETTERS 219

that the selection should be entirely left to the

Bishops.

Another question creating no inconsiderable discus-

sion was whether the Bishops should be required to

pronounce a profession of faith. The problem was

whether the dogma of the Immaculate Conception

should be included. It was contained in no existing

formula of faith. Some were adverse to its introduction. Others thought it impossible for the Council to ignore the existence of this dogma. Some again held that since the dogma had already been declared by the Pope, there could be no necessity to insert it in a Council's decree. For this reason .it ought to be recited in the profession of faith. Nevertheless it was held wiser not to introduce it, for fear of producing upon the Bishops a bad impression. Accordingly it was decided to fall back on the Creed of the Council of Trent.