The only issue in the case was found by the jury for the defendants in error. The judgment should, therefore, be affirmed, unless the court, in the progress of the trial, committed some error to the prejudice of the plaintiff in error. This the latter insists was done.
The first assignment of error relates to the admission in evidence of certain declarations of F. H. McClure, the cashier of the plaintiff in error.
The bill of exceptions states that on the trial the defendants in error offered testimony tending to show that the intestate, Daniel McMillan, was, on April 14, 1876, the owner of 30 shares of the capital stock of the bank standing in his name upon its books, represented by two certificates,-one for 20 and the other for 10 shares; that on the day just mentioned he made his note for the payment, six months after date, to the order of F. A. McClure, of $2,600; that he attached the certificate for 20 shares to this note as security for its payment, and through the medium of the payee, McClure, who was the cashier of the plaintiff in error, the note was discounted by one James K. Hyde; and that the remaining 10 shares were deposited with the plaintiff in error, and held by it for safe-keeping, and not for any other purpose; that on Monday morning, October 23, 1876, McMillan died, and that on the afternoon of that day, McClure, the cashier, having heard of the death of McMillan, sold his 30 shares of stock to E. H. Munger for $4,200, and credited that amount to McMillan on the books of the bank.
The bill of exceptions further stated that the defendants in error introduced evidence tending to show that a few days prior to his death McMillan had paid to the bank the amount due on his note held by Hyde, who had deposited the note with the bank for collection, and that two days after McMillan's death, Hyde, after notice by McClure of the payment of the note, received from the bank its certificate of deposit for the amount due thereon, and the note, with the certificate of stock pledged for its payment, was surrendered by Hyde to the bank, which thus obtained possession of the certificate. Thereupon the defendants in error offered in evidence the following questions and answers contained in the deposition of Hyde: 'Question. What conversation did you have with McClure subsequent to this (subsequent to leaving said note for collection) with reference to that certificate? [20 shares.] Answer. He told me he had full power to transfer it at any time on the books and apply it to the payment of the note. Q. What was said to you by McClure at the time of the payment of the note, in reference to this certificate of 20 shares? A. I desired to purchase it, but there was an understanding that I should hold the certificate of deposit until an administrator was appointed, when an arrangement might be made for its purchase. * * * Q. What statement did McClure make to you at the time of the payment of the note, as to who was making payment? A. He said the payment was made from money which was sent there by McMillan. He told me the money was left there the Wednesday previous. Q. Was any statement made to you by McClure, with reference to this certificate of stock after McMillan's death, in reference to Mrs. McMillan; if so, what? A. He told me after McMillan's death that she preferred to keep the stock. * * * Q. How long after the talk on Wednesday after McMillan's death till the other talk in which McClure told you Mrs. McMillan wished to keep the stock? A. Two months, I presume. Q. Where did the latter take place? A. In the bank; they all took place there.'
The ruling of the court in allowing these questions and answers to be read to the jury, notwithstanding the objection of the plaintiff in error, is now assigned for error. Its contention is that it furnished the money to pay McMillan's note for $2,600, held by Hyde, for which the certificate for 20 shares was pledged, and that it thereby, on the delivery of the certificate to it by Hyde, became entitled to the possession thereof as security for the note. The defendants in error insist that the money to take up the note held by Hyde was paid by their intestate, McMillan. The plaintiff in error complains that upon this issue the statements of McClure, its cashier, made several days after the alleged payment of the note by McMillan, were admitted to show such payment, and insists that this was error, on the ground that the declarations of an agent concerning a past transaction cannot be given in evidence to bind this principal.