"They're the most accomplished set of liars I ever ran across," declared Mr. Pauling, "and the worst of it is, we really haven't an atom of evidence or proof against them. If the _Devonshire_ never turned up, they could claim that she had been sunk by the 'reds' and our own evidence as to the past activities of the villains would lend color to these fellows' tale. Even the fact that Robinson plotted or planned to destroy us or that he was in league with those on the sub would not affect these men. They could hold that he was planted on the _Devonshire_ and the rest of her crew knew nothing of it."
"Yes, that's very true," admitted the Commander, "but I would suggest we put into Barbados and leave this crowd there. Possibly the Admiralty Courts may be able to hold them on some charge."
"I would, but for the fact that if, as Rawlins thinks, the sub is watching us, our going to Barbados would arouse their suspicions and as long as there is a remote chance of getting the leaders I'm going to take it," replied Mr. Pauling.
As he finished speaking, Bancroft and the boys appeared.
"We've found the trouble with the radio!" cried Tom. "And it's all right now. They'd cut the lead-in wire where it passed through an insulating tube and had spliced the insulation together, and on the radio compass they'd taken out a section of wire and replaced it with a bit of stick covered with the insulation where it was connected to a binding post."
"I'll say they're clever rascals!" exclaimed Rawlins. "Well, we can hear any messages they send now even if we don't want to send."
"Personally, I'm sorry that Sam butted that man Robinson overboard," remarked Mr. Pauling who had been deep in thought. "He's bobbed up twice in the nick of time to save your life, Tom, and each time he's killed a man who would have been more valuable alive than dead. Not that I blame him--I owe him a greater debt than I can ever hope to repay--but I do wish that if he's destined to rescue you from every scrape you get into that he could do it without always destroying our evidence. I'd give a great deal to have a chance to put a few questions to that Robinson."
"And I'll bet my boots to a tin whistle he wouldn't have come across with any information," declared Rawlins. "I've been putting two and two together and I've a hunch he's the chap who called himself a 'Yank' when the boys heard him talking on the tramp back in St. John. He was too blamed clever to give away anything and maybe, after all, these men _are_ telling the truth and he was planted on the _Devonshire_ and his friends seized the ship. That would account for their letting Robinson and a boat's crew get away--just to board us you see. By glory, it's such a mixed-up plot within a plot that it's sure got me guessing."