HOBSON, J.A.: _The Crisis in Liberalism_, 1909.

HOLYOAKE: _History of Cooperation_, 1906.

Socialism and Democracy in Europe — Part 183

KNOTT, Y.: _Conservative Socialism_, 1909.

Socialism and Democracy in Europe — Part 183

LECKY, W.E.H.: _Democracy and Liberty_, 1899.

Socialism and Democracy in Europe — Part 183

MACDONALD, J.R.: _The People in Power_, 1900.

MASTERMAN, C.F.G.: _The Condition of England_, 1909.

MCCARTHY, J.: _The Epoch of Reform_, 1882. For Chartism and the reform movements of the nineteenth century democracy.

MONEY, CHIOZZA: _Riches and Poverty_, 1911.

NICHOLSON, J.S.: _History, Progress and Ideals of Socialism._ A criticism of the Socialist viewpoint.

NOEL, CONRAD: _The Labor Party._ A criticism of the attitude of Liberals and Conservatives toward the social problems. From the Labor Party viewpoint.

SNOWDEN, P.: _The Socialist Budget_, 1907.

TOWLER, W.G.: _Municipal Socialism._ The anti-Socialist viewpoint.

_The Times_: _The Socialist Movement in Great Britain_, 1909. A reprint of a series of carefully prepared articles in _The Times._

VILLIERS, B.: _The Opportunity of Liberalism_, 1904.

---- _The Socialist Movement in England_, 1908.

WEBB, S.: _Wanted--A Program: An Appeal to the Liberal Party_, 1888.

WEBB, B. and S.: _Industrial Democracy_, 1902.

---- _The History of Trade Unionism_, 1911.

Yves Guyot, the distinguished French publicist, told the writer that there was only one compact, disciplined political party in France, the United Socialists. Other than the Socialists, there is no well-organized group in the Chamber of Deputies. The Right, Center, and Left coalesce almost insensibly into each other. Party platforms and party loyalty are replaced by a political individualism that to an American politician would seem like political anarchy.

The Chamber of Deputies is supreme--the ministry stands or falls upon its majority's behest. This gives to the deputy a peculiar personal power. He is only loosely affiliated with his group, is a powerful factor in the government of the Republic, and is directly dependent upon his constituents for his tenure in office. The result is a personal, rather then a party, system of politics.

This remarkably decentralized system of representative governance is counterbalanced by a highly efficient and completely centralized system of administration, which is based on civil service, and outlives all the mutations of ministries and shifting of deputies. The ministry, naturally, has theoretical control over the administrative officials. During the campaign for reorganizing the army and navy, and the disestablishment of the Church, under the Radical-Socialist _bloc_, a few years ago, General André, acting for the ministry, resorted to a comprehensive system of espionage to ferret out the undesirable officers. Every commune has its official scrutinizer, who reports the doings of the employees to the government.