J.C. Hallman (born 1967) is an American author, essayist, and researcher. His work has been widely published in Harper's, GQ, The Baffler, Tin House Magazine, The New Republic, and elsewhere. He is the author of six books, and his nonfiction combines memoir, history, journalism, and travelogue, including the highly acclaimed B & Me: A True Story of Literary Arousal, a book about love, literature, and modern life.
Early life and career
Hallman grew up in Southern California and studied creative writing at the University of Pittsburgh, the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, and Johns Hopkins University. In the mid-1990s, Hallman worked as a table games dealer in Atlantic City for five years, during a period when the city was experiencing an increase in suicides, including a close friend of Hallman's. This incident is detailed in his 2015 Harper’s essay "Getting to the End."
Say Anarcha: A Young Woman, a Devious Surgeon, and the Harrowing Birth of Modern Women's Health
In 2017, NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio launched a commission to evaluate controversial monuments in the city, including the statue of controversial surgeon J. Marion Sims, in Central Park. During the 90 day evaluation period, Hallman's essay about the Sims monument, "Monumental Error," appeared on the cover of Harper's Magazine, and was published during the time the Public Design Commission held public forums for the evaluation of these monuments. The piece contributed to the greater, nationwide debate about the role of Confederate monuments. The article was distributed to the entire commission. The Sims statue was voted out by unanimous decision and removed in April 2018.
Hallman is publishing a book about the young enslaved woman who was Sims's first experimental subject, Anarcha Westcott. He was prompted to explore her life after finding the first evidence of Westcott's existence that didn't come from Sims's own writings. Hallman was quoted in The Guardian about the removal of the statue, saying "It’s the first time, and hopefully not the last, that a statue in New York City was removed explicitly because of questions about the content of the monument."
After the statue's removal, Hallman published several op-eds detailing Sims's career as a spy in Paris, and shared the story of another controversial statue of Sims in Montgomery, Alabama. He published a piece with the African American Policy Forum about the lukewarm attention that medical organizations gave to the Sims legacy, despite Sims's impact on vaccine hesitancy in the African American community during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Hallman was interviewed about his work in uncovering the details of Anarcha's life and death by filmmaker Josh Carples in the documentary Remembering Anarcha, which was an official selection of the San Francisco Black Film Festival in 2020. Hallman linked Sims’ experimentations on young black women to the ongoing health crisis in Africa regarding the treatment of obstetric fistula, a condition that results from complications during childbirth, in a piece about Alica Emasu, founder of the Terrewode Women's Community Hospital, for The Baffler. Up until recently, Sims has been regularly lauded as the father of gynecology and had worked to repair fistulas, though Hallman uncovered his radical experimentations on enslaved men and women to read "like snippets lifted from the pages of a horror story," questioning Sims's altruism due to his feelings of disgust at diseases of the female pelvic region. Rather, Hallman notes, Sims was motivated by a chance at immortalizing himself in the annals of medical history.
Say Anarcha: A Young Woman, a Devious Surgeon, and the Harrowing Birth of Modern Women's Health was published in June 2023, and was widely praised. The New York Times called the book "a truly astounding tale...compelling and well-researched" and "an important book [that] deserves to be read widely." The Brooklyn Rail called the book "an instant classic" and "a new masterpiece" and noted that "Hallman had done what no scholar had previously succeeded in doing, namely unearthing information about Anarcha independent of Sims’s tendentious accounts of her life." Publisher's Weekly praised the book in a starred review as "innovative and riveting...a must-read," and Booklist, also a starred review, called the book "commanding and affecting...and grimly relevant."
Say Anarcha reveals Anarcha's final resting place, a marked grave in a remote Virginia forest. After completing the book, Hallman began a search for descendants of Anarcha and her husband, Lorenzo. He succeeded in locating living family members, who have since visited the gravesite. Work is ongoing to ensure that the gravesite is properly protected and memorialized.