Hugh Pigot (5 September 1769 – 21 September 1797) was an officer in the Royal Navy. Through his connections and their patronage, he was able to rise to the rank of captain, despite apparently poor leadership skills and a reputation for brutality. While he was captain of Hermione, he eventually provoked his men to mutiny. The mutiny, which became one of the bloodiest in the history of the Royal Navy, left Pigot and nine other officers dead. The Navy hunted down and executed a number of the mutineers and recaptured his ship from the Spanish, to whom the mutineers had turned it over.
Family and early life
Pigot was born in Patshull, Staffordshire, on 5 September 1769, the second son of Admiral Hugh Pigot. His mother was Hugh's second wife, Frances, who was the daughter of Sir Richard Wrottesley. The younger Hugh embarked on his naval career on 10 March 1782, when he joined the 50-gun as an admiral's servant. He sailed from the Hamoaze with the Jupiter to the West Indies, where his father was flying his flag aboard the 90-gun . Pigot was advanced to midshipman or masters' mate on 1 October 1784, and received his commission as lieutenant on 21 September 1790. He received his first command, that of the sloop , on 10 February 1794, and was assigned to operate on the Jamaica station.
First commands
Whilst in command of the Swan, Pigot rammed the merchant ship Canada in the English Channel in May 1794. He placed the blame for the mishap on the master of the merchant. Four months later Pigot was posted to the 32-gun as her captain. During a nine-month period, he ordered at least 85 floggings, the equivalent of half the crew; two men died from their injuries. In July 1795 he was involved in another collision with the Mercury, an American ship, near Santo Domingo. He again blamed the master of the other ship. But when he had the man seized and flogged he created a diplomatic incident. Pigot was brought to court-martial, but that let him off with an apology. He was initially to return to England after this, but Admiral Sir Hyde Parker, then in command at Jamaica, thought that Pigot had been represented badly and allowed him to transfer to the 32-gun instead.
Hermione
Pigot took command of HMS Hermione on 10 February 1797, making a habit of giving preferential treatment to members of the crew who had previously served under him. The ship was sent to patrol the Mona Passage between the Dominican Republic and Puerto Rico. Pigot destroyed three privateers at Puerto Rico on 22 March 1797. In April Pigot, aboard Hermione, and acting in company with , , and , succeeded in cutting out nine merchant ships at the Battle of Jean-Rabel under fire from enemy batteries, and without losing a single man. Pigot’s despatch to the Admiralty did not mention the contributions that other ships and officers had made to the operation. In an incident in May 1797 the Hermione narrowly escaped being wrecked thanks to the efforts of one of her lieutenants, Harris, but a ship sailing in company with the Hermione went aground. Pigot blamed Harris, however, and insisted upon an inquiry. Though Harris was exonerated, he immediately left the ship to serve on another. Pigot had by now developed a reputation for excessive brutality. On 6 September 1797, and in company with and , she captured a 6-gun Spanish privateer.
Mutiny
Midshipman David Casey was an experienced midshipman who had served with credit under Captain Pigot during the previous months, but his disrating was a primary trigger to the mutiny. About a week before the mutiny, Casey was at his station on the main top, and the captain noticed a reef knot which had not been tied by one of the sailors under his supervision. Casey was brought before the captain, and while he took full responsibility for it, Pigot demanded that Casey get on his knees and beg for forgiveness. This would have been a terrible insult for a gentleman, and Casey refused. The captain gave him 12 lashes, and he was disrated, which would end his career as a naval officer. The crew felt Casey was punished unfairly, and the topmen began to plot mutiny.