In these languages, every element in the sentence which is not incorporated in the verb has, in fact, no syntax at all. The verbal exhausts all the formal portion of the language. The relations of the other words are intimated by their position. Thus _ni-tlaçotlaz-nequia_, I wished to love, is literally, “I, I shall love, I wished.” _Tlaçotlaz_ is the first person singular of the future; _ni-nequia_, I wished; which is divided, and the future form inserted. The same expression may stand thus: _ni-c-nequia-tlaço-tlaz_, where the _c_ is an intercalated relative pronoun, and the literal rendering is, “I it wished, I shall love.”

In the Lule language the construction with an infinitive is simply that the two verbs follow each other in the same person, as _caic tucuec_, “I am accustomed to eat,” literally, “I am accustomed, I eat.”

Essays of an Americanist — Part 179

None of these devices fulfils all the uses of the infinitive, and hence they are all inferior to it.

Essays of an Americanist — Part 179

In languages which lack formal elements, the deficiency must be supplied by the mind. Words are merely placed in juxtaposition, and their relationship guessed at. Thus, when a language constructs its cases merely by prefixing prepositions to the unaltered noun, there is no grammatical form; in the Mbaya language _e-tiboa_ is translated “through me,” but it is really “I, through;” _l’emani_, is rendered “he wishes,” but it is strictly, “he, wish.”

Essays of an Americanist — Part 179

In such languages the same collocation of words often corresponds to quite different meanings, as the precise relation of the thoughts is not defined by any formal elements. This is well illustrated in the Tupi tongue. The word _uba_ is “father;” with the pronoun of the third person prefixed it is _tuba_, literally “he, father.” This may mean either “his father,” or “he is a father,” or “he has a father,” just as the sense of the rest of the sentence requires.

Certainly a language which thus leaves confounded together ideas so distinct as these, is inferior to one which discriminates them; and this is why the formal elements of a tongue are so important to intellectual growth. The Tupis may be an energetic and skillful people, but with their language they can never take a position as masters in the realm of ideas.