S this man my father, or was it simply a coincidence that John Evans resembled him so strongly? The points of resemblance must be striking indeed to make the likeness apparent under such altered conditions and in the brief space of time before distance rendered his features indistinguishable. It seemed barely possible that I could recognise my father, the man in clerical dress, clean-shaven, haggard and grey with fatigue and starvation, abject and fierce by turns with fear and despair, in this bearded cricketer, with the sunny tint of health upon his cheek, a fearless bearing, and the placid expression of happiness and well being. And yet a dozen arguments favoured the supposition by clearing away as many anomalies that had made my mother's behaviour unaccountable and mysterious. If my father stood in danger of the law for some past offence, my mother was compelled for his sake, for her own and our welfare to observe secrecy and even to practise deception in all that regarded his existence, since a single word dropped in accident by us might betray him to his enemies. In venturing to return to England, where he stood within easy reach of apprehension, his first object would be to assume disguise and another name, to conceal his identity. The next step to avert suspicion would be to declare that he was dead. Little mother's changing colour, and the absence of grief in making this announcement and putting on her widow's weeds, had already suggested to my mind the possibility that my father was not really dead. I had the evidence of my own senses to show that my mother's love for my father had not warped by ten years of separation, nor his for her, and their first natural desire would be to live near each other. With that view little mother had resolved to leave Wood Green, where it would be dangerous for my father to come again, and bound us to secrecy with regard to the place where we were in future to reside. Those mysterious visits to Aunt Laura may have been but pretexts for meeting my father and making arrangements for the future—indeed, as Elsie had laughingly suggested, Aunt Laura might turn out to be John Evans in disguise. My mother's trepidation in meeting James Redmond, whose professions of friendship for herself and “po'r George” she had reason to believe were false, was easily to be traced to her fear that his malevolent purpose would lead him to track her down if his suspicions were aroused by any unguarded act or course of conduct for which she could offer no plausible explanation.
“What is the matter with you, you small-sized Sphinx?” asked Elsie, with a nip that effectually broke off my speculations. “You have been staring stonily at nothing ever since we passed John Evans: he seems to have petrified you and little mother as well. There's no getting a word out of either, and I believe you have noticed nothing for the past quarter of an hour.”
Indeed, I should have found it difficult to tell what had passed before my eyes in that time. I was hazily conscious of having passed through a sleepy street with shops on either side, and that was all. We were now on the outskirts of the town again, on the side of the hill farthest from the station, and between the scattered houses one got glimpses of the deep wooded valley, flashed with bright spots and streaks here and there, where the bend of the beck caught the light, a faint blue mist closing in the distance. Presently our driver drew in by the footpath and stopped.
“Is this our house?” asked mother, in a tone of doubt that caused Elsie and me to look round sharply with the apprehension, on my part, that it might be too mean—even for our humble tastes. For the houses we had passed were strikingly plain, not to say ugly, being all built of dark stone, quite square, with small windows, and no attempt at any external ornament—as if the practical builders had found that Nature supplied all that any human being could require in the beauty of the surrounding country.
“Ay; if thee 'rt Mrs. Heatherly, this be thy home for a certainty,” replied the old man, throwing the reins on the back of his Galloway. “'Tain't exac'ly the kind of house Ah should choose for myself now, though it was as good a house as any this side o' the vicar's in Farleigh,” he added, getting down. “So be thee don't like it, thee'll ha' to call John Evans to account, for it's him as has decked it out this outlandish like.”