There are in Riley's _Memorials_ about this date several other references to aldermen acting with the Mayor, thus, on the 14th September 1301: 'Walter Swan appeared before Sir Elias Russel, Mayor of London, and other aldermen then present';[249] and in December 1310 Roger de Eure having insulted and assaulted Richard de Gloucestre, alderman, the two parties 'appeared in the Guildhall before Sir Richer [de Refham] the Mayor, and the aldermen.'[250]
In 1311 (4 Edw. II.) the form of description of the governors was 'The Mayor, Aldermen and Common Council of the City.'[251] From this time the general form was either this or 'The Mayor, Aldermen and Commonalty.' It is necessary, however, to mention that a congregation of Mayor and aldermen is referred to in Fitz-Ailwin's Assize of 1189.[252]
The title of 'echevin,' as applied to a governor of the city, is at present only known to us as used in the Oath of the Commune, found by Mr. Round, and it may therefore have had a very short existence. It is possible that aldermen were elected on to the Mayor's Council under the title of 'echevins.' This, however, is not the opinion of Mr. Round, who is inclined to believe that the body of echevins became in course of time the Court of Common Council.
The whole question is at present one of great difficulty, and I only state the facts here without venturing to express any confident opinion until more evidence is forthcoming.
We may be allowed to think that too great an importance has been ascribed to the position of the early aldermen in connection with their wards. It is generally affirmed that the aldermen were hereditary owners of the various wards, on account of the fact that the wards were named after them, an instance of which practice remains in Farringdon, Bassishaw and Basingshall. There is no evidence of this proprietorship, and it seems improbable on the face of it. Mr. Round believes that what an alderman inherited can only have been the aldermanry of his ward, like, he suggests, an hereditary sheriff.
Mr. Baddeley writes that 'early in 1276 we find mention made of "the ward of Henry de Frowyk within the Gate" (_i.e._, Cripplegate), and ten years later (_circ._ 1285) he figures in the earliest list of aldermen extant in the city's records as alderman of the same ward.'[253]