October 1, 1942, Decided by the Board

Canadian Indians -- Definition -- Act of April 2, 1928.

EXCLUDED BY BOARD OF SPECIAL INQUIRY:

In the Matter of S---

Act of 1924 -- Immigrants without immigration visas.

In the Matter of S---

Alien Registration Act of 1940 -- No permits to enter.

In the Matter of S---

Executive Order 8766 -- No passports.

OPINION:

Mr. Joseph Minton, for the Immigration and Naturalization Service.

Mr. Richard P. Lott, Board attorney-examiner.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE: *309 The appellant, P--- R--- S--- (56107/290) appeared before a board of special inquiry held in Montreal, Canada, for admission for indefinite residence. The appellant, I--- D--- (56128/331) applied at the port of Oroville, Wash., for admission for indefinite residence. The appellant, E--- L--- (56107/553) applied at the port of Van Buren, Me., for admission for indefinite residence. Each appellant claimed the right of entry without documents as an Indian. Each is of white blood but makes claim to Indian status under the provisions of the Canadian Indian Act and therefore the right to pass under the Act of April 2, 1928 FN1 (8 U.S.C.A., sec. 226 (a) and General Order 109 of July 18, 1928, and Instruction No. 9 of January 23, 1942). The respective boards of special inquiry denied their claims to Indian status and excluded them on the grounds above stated by reason of their lack of passports and visas. Each appeals.

FN1 the Immigration Act of 1924 shall not be construed to apply to the right of American Indians born in Canada to pass the borders of the United States: Provided, That this right shall not extend to persons whose membership in Indian tribes or families is created by adoption.

DISCUSSION: *310 The question in each case is identical: Is a white woman married to an Indian to be considered an Indian under the provisions of the Canadian Indian Act and especially section 2 (d) thereof which defines "Indian" as follows:

(i) Any male person of Indian blood reputed to belong to a particular band.

(ii) Any child of such person.

(iii) Any woman who is or was lawfully married to such person (ch. 98, Rev. Stat. of Canada, 1927).

The administrative interpretation of this question has not been uniform. Under date of August 8, 1928, a Central Office letter carried in file No. 55466/182-B advised the field that General Order 109 applied to all immigration laws and "you are advised that the question as to whether an alien is properly within the terms of General Order 109 should be determined, not by the degree of any particular blood, but by determining if the alien is actually recognized as a Canadian-born American Indian." It will be observed that the foregoing suggests a political rather than an ethnological interpretation.

Some months later, on March 26, 1929, the Board of Review in an opinion advised that Indians born in the United States who had naturalized in Canada come within the act of 1928 and General Order 109 because the term "Indian" is ethnological rather than political. The reasoning of this opinion was prompted by solicitude for Indians born in the United States. It is doubtful, however, whether this opinion is of ruling force in view of the Solicitor's opinion of November 16, 1933, which holds that an enfranchised Canadian Indian is not entitled to the benefits of the act of 1928, an opinion that has been consistently followed by the Board of Review (and the Board of Immigration Appeals). See for example In re B--- (56068/34).

Under date of April 12, 1932, the Board of Review held that a child born of a white mother who was the wife of a half-breed Canadian Indian was inadmissible as an immigrant. The Indian status of the child was not taken into consideration, but the facts of the case indicated that the father was not an enrolled Indian. The decision, therefore, is neither an ethnological nor a political interpretation, although, if either, it is a political interpretation. (See R--- K--- (55808/379).)