Where a Girl, like this, could be; and how employed during the time; is not difficult to imagine. Not with a Lover certainly, say you! You would be happy, Sir, if all you beg should be allowed you. Not with a Lover, Sir! Eighteen, let me remind you, is a critical Age; and what would not a Woman do, that had made an Escape, to recover her own Credit, and screen her Lover. I pretend to no Knowledge of this, as having been the Case with Respect to the Girl of whom I speak; but, if we are to reason, let us do it freely; and what appears so likely?

The Description she gave of the Room in which she had been confined, is urged by you to justify; but, Sir, that Circumstance alone ought to condemn her. Let me not be understood to speak of that Description, which she gave after she had seen it: That Subterfuge may serve for the Excuse of those who will be found to want it. But let us now enquire with better Judgment: Let us, Sir, appeal to that Account she gave before the sitting Alderman, by whom she was first examined; and we shall find it countenance the worst that can be thought against her. Observe the Articles.

The Story of Elizabeth Canning Considered — Part 11

She described it to be a _dark_ Room; in which she lay upon the _Boards_; in which there was nothing except _a Grate_ with a Gown in it; and a _few Pictures_ over the Chimney; from which she made her Escape by _forcing down some Boards_, and out of which she had before discovered the Face of a Coachman, through certain _Cracks_ in the Side.

The Story of Elizabeth Canning Considered — Part 11

Let those who have seen the Room speak whether this was a Description of it. They will answer No. No, not in any one Particular. Far from being _dark_, there are _two Windows_ in it. These have Casements which were unfastened, out at which she might have _escaped_, had she been confined in it; so that pulling down of Boards to that Purpose could not be necessary: Out at these also, I suppose, the might have _seen this Coachman_, so that she needed not to peep through Cracks. There was no Grate in the Chimney: so that no body could have been guilty of this most housewifely Trick of putting a Gown in one: Nor were there any Pictures over it. Of the latter there was no Probability to be any, because the House had no Profusion of Furniture, and this was a Room of Lumber: And it is palpable there could have been no Grate in the Chimney of a long Time; for the whole Expanse of it was found covered and overspread with Cobwebs, the Work of many Generations of unmolested Spiders. Oh Providence that assists in these Discoveries!

The Story of Elizabeth Canning Considered — Part 11