Governor Pennington, who was a courtly gentleman of the old school and something of a wag, answered very gravely:
"Mr. Dodd, I agree with you about 'Elmer's Forms.' It is an excellent office book. I consult it every day and should be sorry to be without it, but you know, Mr. Dodd, that I am always ready to oblige you, and I will cheerfully let you have it if you will promise in writing to return it when I need it." "Certainly," said Mr. Dodd, and dashed off a serio-comic agreement to return the book when called for. He folded the document and handed it to the Governor, and the Governor handed him his own missing book.
I told this to my old Yale friend, William Pennington of Paterson, a nephew of the Governor, who chuckled and said, "I can see him doing it."
Governor Pennington used often to associate young Dodd with him in the trial of causes. He had been Governor under the old Constitution and _ex-officio_ Chancellor, but was not scholarly and relied very much on his knowledge of the world, tact, and strong common sense. Mr. Dodd once told me that while the Governor knew very little law, he was a most dangerous antagonist before a jury. If he had the close he was almost sure to get the jury with him, and if you had the close he would sit in front of the jury and smile your speech away.
Mr. Dodd is my authority for this story: Ex-Governor Daniel Haines, the Justice of the Supreme Court who held the Essex Circuit, was a man of strict views, and Mr. Cortlandt Parker, the Prosecutor of the Pleas, was discharging his important duties with a force and efficiency worthy of national issues and a wider stage, and so, what with the austerity of the Judge and the zeal of the Prosecutor, the way of the transgressor was growing hard, and it was getting to be common talk among the rounders and hangers-on at the courthouse that if a man was indicted he might as well plead guilty at once and save the county the expense of a trial. Some malefactor, with more money or spirit than the others, paid Governor Pennington a good fee and instructed him to fight. The Governor had been informed of the current gossip, and thought he would see what he could make out of it. So he told the jury in his most impressive manner, that a man is taken to be innocent until he is proved to be guilty; that this is the palladium of our liberties; and that he feared that this precious, fundamental right was not sufficiently borne in mind, even in the courthouse of the county of Essex, and that it was too much assumed that conviction ought to follow indictment. At this point Judge Haines, with a flushed face and his eyes shining brightly through his gold-rimmed spectacles, interrupted the Governor, and said that he had heard the remarks of the distinguished counsel with much surprise and regret; that they conveyed an imputation upon the Court itself--an intimation that he was derelict in his duty toward an important class of suitors, the defendants in criminal cases, and that he desired to know and now asked counsel to state from what persons he heard these strictures upon the Court. Governor Pennington, with his usual urbanity, bowed and said: "It is mainly from the criminals themselves." This answer occasioned such a sudden revulsion of thought and feeling as to discompose the Judge and convulse the Bar.