’LL tell you why I think Hartigan was I shot by Badger,” continued Carroll evenly. “You yourselves saw the man re-enact his part in last night’s tragedy. I, for one, am anything but gullible, and I say frankly that I believe the man was telling the truth.”

“And I,” said Denson.

Six Seconds of Darkness/Chapter 10

“Me, too,” agreed Hall.

Six Seconds of Darkness/Chapter 10

“So far so good. You also noticed that he handled his revolver with two hands. He is physically weak and puny. From the very way he handled the gun it was self-evident that he is not used to firearms. Why, then, suppose that his aim was so deadly accurate that he hit his target even in the dark? Revolver shooting is a difficult art at best, and it would be stretching one’s credulity to believe that he hit the man he was firing at, especially as Hartigan—so he says—had meanwhile snapped off the lights.

Six Seconds of Darkness/Chapter 10

“But it is certain that he fired. Where, then, did his bullet go? Here.” He took his stand on the spot where Badger had stood and clutched the revolver in two hands, waving it as Badger had done. “If Harrelson and Hamilton had come through that door yonder they would have been visible beyond the left side of the screen. Badger already had his trigger back probably—his gun fired, and the bullet struck Hartigan. You can see the bullet hole beyond in the screen, just at the height of Hartigan’s wrist, and I am pretty well convinced, after examining it again in the light of Badger’s story, that the bullet which went through that screen was headed into the room—not toward the wall. What do you think, Mr. Hall?”

“I think you’re dead right—and in so far as that little old man is concerned I’m glad.”

“And you, Denson?”

The lawyer pulled a wry face.

“Since I have agreed to be honest, I must admit that I agree with you—much as I hate to.”

“Why?”

“With Badger eliminated, the burden of guilt is thrown on one of my two clients—Miss Duval or Mr. Harrelson.”

“You forgot Hartigan,” suggested Carroll.

“By George!” Hall broke out. “I had forgotten Hartigan! We’ve proved his story true up to the present; but, still, he might have shot Hamilton and thought that Hamilton shot him.”

“He might, yes,” agreed Carroll. “But one fact stands out with puzzling significance—it is agreed that no shot was fired before the lights went out, and it is a virtual certainty that Hartigan was shot in the dark. Are we to believe, then, that he shot after switching the lights back on and after he had been wounded?”

“He fired a shot at some time!” snapped Denson bluntly. “We know that!”

“Yes,” said Carroll, “so we do. I had forgotten that.”

Hall flashed him a keen glance.

“What are you driving at, anyway, Carroll? Hartigan lied to us when he told his first story; he admitted it when he came in to see us at headquarters with his carefully thought-out revision. Rollins found Hartigan unconscious behind that screen; he found in his pocket a revolver from which one shot had been fired. His deductions were absolutely logical. Why should we believe every detail of the crook’s story?”

“We shouldn’t,” said Carroll simply. “We shouldn’t believe any one’s story—even that of Miss Duval.”

“Meaning?” interjected Denson eagerly.

“That, of our four choices, three are mistaken—either deliberately or through circumstances. Remember, this case reeks with the unusual; we have one of the most prominent men in the city murdered in his own study—and immediately following the murder the confessions of his ward, a society belle; a young artist, and a half-crazy old man. Then the head of our regular detective force brings in a burglar so tightly hemmed around with a net of circumstantial evidence that he wouldn’t have a breathing chance before a jury.

“A doctor’s investigation proves beyond peradventure of a doubt that the man was shot only once. And while every one present admits that three shots might have been fired—the likelihood is that there were only two; one fired in the dark, and the other immediately after the lights were snapped on.”

“You’re wrong,” said Denson earnestly. “You yourself admitted that what seemed to be the echo of the first shot in the dark might have been a second shot.”

“No, I don’t forget that. I’ll even go so far as to admit that two shots were fired in the dark. But this much I will say, I have been trying to find out who fired the shot which came after the lights went on again. I am strongly convinced that that is the shot which killed Mr. Hamilton.”

“I’d like to believe you,” said Denson, “but I can’t.”

“Why?”

“The stories all tally that Hamilton was sinking to the floor when the lights were snapped on.”