Novak v. City of Parma, No. 21-3290, is a 2022 decision of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit granting qualified immunity to the city of Parma, Ohio, and its officials for prosecuting Anthony Novak over a Facebook page that parodied the Parma Police Department's page. The case drew widespread attention when The Onion, a satirical newspaper, filed a humorous but sincere amicus curiae brief supporting Novak's petition to the United States Supreme Court for certiorari; that petition was denied in February 2023.
The parody page, which strongly resembled the real page, had led to Novak's arrest in March 2016 and a subsequent trial for disrupting public services, which resulted in Novak's acquittal. Novak then brought suit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for retaliation and prior restraint. An initial decision of the Sixth Circuit in July 2019 allowed most of the suit to proceed, leading to a February 2021 ruling that Novak's arresting officers both had probable cause and were protected by qualified immunity, which the Sixth Circuit upheld in April 2022.
In August 2022, Novak petitioned the United States Supreme Court for certiorari, asking them to review the case. The Onion amicus brief, submitted at the suggestion of Novak's counsel and drafted in consultation with the publication's writers, emphasized the importance of parody in political discourse, while also making absurd claims such as that The Onion "enjoys a daily readership of 4.3 trillion" and calling the federal judiciary "Latin dorks". The Babylon Bee, a conservative satirical publication, filed an amicus brief as well. The subsequent denial of certiorari let stand the Sixth Circuit's decision.
Background
"We no crime" Facebook page
In March 2016, Parma, Ohio, resident Anthony Novak created a page on Facebook mimicking that of the Parma Police Department, except with their slogan of "We know crime" changed to "We no crime" in the "About" section. He did so anonymously from his phone while waiting for a bus, to express his criticism of the department's policies. Posts on the page included job postings that discouraged applications by members of minorities and an offer of "free abortions for teenagers provided by police in the Wal-Mart parking lot". Novak took the page down after about 12 hours, during which time 10 people reported it to the police via 9-1-1.
Novak deleted comments that called the page fake, and when the police department posted to the real page warning about his page, he made the same warning on his.
Novak's arrest and prosecution
Parma Police obtained Novak's information from Facebook and arrested him on March 25, 2016, a few weeks after the page's brief existence. They also searched his residence and seized his electronic devices. Novak was accused of disrupting public services, a fourth-degree felony; he spent three or four days in jail. He was indicted in April.
At trial in August 2016, prosecutors argued that Novak's actions had disrupted police activities. Novak's attorney, Gary Vick, countered that the department's statements at the time had focused on the derogatory nature of Novak's comments. The jury acquitted and Novak immediately announced plans to sue.
Section 1983 suit
In October 2017, Novak brought a federal suit in the Northern District of Ohio against the City of Parma and two investigating officers under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging retaliation and prior restraint in violation of the First Amendment and violations of the Fourth Amendment. The city moved to dismiss, asserting qualified immunity. District Judge Dan Polster denied most parts of the city's motion to dismiss in April 2018.