_Aniouta_ owed some of its success to Popov's libretto, which was a mild protest against the feudal aristocracy. The peasant Miron sings in the first act some naïve verses in which he bewails the hard fate of the peasant; "Ah, how tired I am," he says. "Why are we peasants not nobles? Then, we might crunch sugar all day long, lie warm a'top of the stove and ride in our carriages." If we put aside the idea that Volkov's _Taniousha_ was the first opera written by a Russian composer, then this honour must be rendered to Fomin's _Aniouta_.
Contemporary proof of the immense success of _The Miller_ (_Melnik-Koldoun_) is not wanting. The Dramatic Dictionary for 1787 informs us that it was played twenty-seven nights running and that the theatre was always full. Not only were the Russians pleased with it, but it interested the foreigners at Court. The most obvious proof of its popularity may be found in the numerous inferior imitations which followed in its wake.
The libretto of _The Miller_, like that of _Aniouta_, was tinged by a cautious liberalism. Here it is not a peasant, but a peasant proprietor, who "tills and toils and from the peasants collects the rent" who plays the principal rôle. The part of the Miller was admirably acted by Kroutitsky (1754-83), who, after the first performance, was called to the Empress's box and presented with a gold watch. But undoubtedly Fomin's music helped the success of the opera. The work has been reissued with an interesting preface by P. Karatagyn (Jurgenson, Moscow), so that it is easily accessible to those who are interested in the early history of Russian opera. The music is somewhat amateurish and lacking in technical resource. Fomin does not venture upon a chorus, although there are occasionally couplets with choral refrains; lyric follows lyric, and the duets are really alternating solos with a few phrases in thirds at the close of the verses. But the public in Russia in the eighteenth century was not very critical, and took delight in the novel sensation of hearing folk-songs on the stage. In the second act the heroine Aniouta sings a pretty melody based on a familiar folk-tune which awakened great enthusiasm among the audience. The songs and their words stand so close to the original folk-tunes that no doubt they carried away all the occupants of the pit and the cheap places; while, for the more exacting portion of the audience, the rôle of the Miller was written in the conventional style of the _opera buffa_. This judicious combination pleased all tastes.