“African Artifacts, Art Institute of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois” by Ken Lund is marked with CC BY-SA 2.0. A recent conference stirred up an often overlooked aspect of the debate on returning Africa's stolen cultural artifacts: the importance of audio and visual material. Over 90 percent of the material cultural legacy of sub-Saharan Africa remains preserved and housed outside of the African continent, experts believe. Since as far back as 1944 when descendants of the former Toucouleur Empire began demanding the return of thousands of pieces of significant cultural heritage to their community including the saber of their founder, El Hadj Omar Tall, there have been calls and ongoing debates on the return of many stolen African artifacts still held in the collections of Western museums. What started off as a niche debate among certain circles has since entered the public domain. Now, calls are mounting from Africans in the continent and in the diaspora for restitution — the process through which objects stolen by colonial powers can be returned to their communities of origin — as well as repatriation — the process by which stolen or looted cultural materials are returned to a nation or state at the request of a government. Tangible materials have taken centre stage in the debate, overshadowing the large repository of audio-visual materials kept in European archives. The pilferage of Africa’s cultural heritage during the colonisation era was not only limited to sculptures, trinkets, and other tangible cultural items. It also extended to sound and visual recordings. However, unlike the artifacts, few organisations, communities or governments have prioritised their call for the return of the rich archival film footage and audio recordings taken during the colonial period. “Our culture will not grow if we don’t have access to this aspect of our cultural heritage beyond the sculptures and artefacts.” Dr. Nyairo This quote by Dr. Nyairo — a cultural analyst, independent researcher who works on cultural memory projects, and the author of Kenya @50 sums up the deliberations of a two-day cultural event that was organised by the British Council in Nairobi recently. “We don’t talk about films, field recordings. We must also pay attention to Sound and visual recordings and start advocating for the return or sharing of these recordings as well. Our culture will not grow if we don’t have access to this aspect of our cultural heritage beyond the sculptures and artifacts.” Dr. Nyairo noted. Dr. Nyairo was the keynote speaker at this year's annual Culture Grows symposium, where the theme was ‘Decolonisation & Cultural Heritage in Africa.’ (the full footage of day 1 of the two-day event) In 2015, a 65-year-old audio recording of a song called “Chemirocha,” sung by a group of young girls from the Kipsigis community in Kenya’s Rift Valley was returned to its home where it was first collected. It is among thousands of field recordings made by ethnomusicologist Huey Tracey — a British emigrant who arrived in Zimbabwe in 1921. He together with his wife Barbara Tracey, traveled across Africa doing field recordings of traditional folk songs. Between the 1920s and the 1970s, they made over 35,000 recordings of African folk music. He later founded the International Library of African Music (ILAM) — the largest repository of African music in the world which preserves thousands of historical recordings going back to 1929. Sadly, similar stories to that of Chemirocha — that tell of the successful and joyous restitution of Africa’s audio or visual heritage are hard to come by. The hardest part of this process of restitution has been knowing who is holding what, and where, noted Jim Chuchu and Njoki Ngumi from The Nest Collective while speaking to DW. Their initiative, the International Inventories Program, has built a digital and online database of 32,000 Kenyan cultural items held in the “Global North.” “We felt it was important, because how can you ask for things if you don't know what they look like and where they are?” said Jim Chuchu to DW As Dr. Nyairo urged the restitution debate and initiatives to also demand and find ways around the technological challenges of sound and video recordings, her speech sought to focus beyond their return. “When we retrieve, we have a thousand opportunities to sample, revise and remix as we create again. That is how culture grows.” Her argument leans towards the submerging of these copious amounts of video and audio footage because, as she argued: “Culture is not static. Culture leans back to pick from the present. Not to bury itself in purity.” Her caution not to bury culture in purity resonated with calls by other speakers at the cultural forum.