To be more particular: In what poet of the time of Edward IV., or for a century afterwards, will the Dean of Exeter find what we frequently meet with in the _Battle of Hastings_, No. 1, and No. 2, at the conclusion of speeches-- “_Thus he_;”-- “_Thus Leofwine_;”-- “_He said_; and as,” &c? In none I am confident. This latter is a form of expression in heroick poetry, that Pope has frequently made use of in his Homer (from whence Chatterton undoubtedly copied it), and was sometimes employed by Dryden and Cowley; but I believe it will not be easy to trace it to Harrington or Spenser; most assuredly it cannot be traced up to the fifteenth century. ----In what English poem of that age will he find similies dressed in the modern garb with which Chatterton has clothed them throughout these pieces?-- “_As when_ a flight of cranes, &c.-- _So_ prone,” &c.-- “_As when_ a drove of wolves, &c. _So_ fought,” &c. &c.-- If the reverend Antiquarian can find this kind of phraseology in any one poet of the time of King Edward IV., or even for fifty years afterwards, I will acknowledge the antiquity of every line contained in his quarto volume. Most assuredly neither he nor his colleague can produce any such instance. Even in the latter end of the _sixteenth_ century, (a large bound from 1460,) poetical comparisons, of the kind here alluded to, were _generally_ expressed either thus-- “_Look how_ the crown that Ariadne wore, &c. _So_,” &c. “_Look how_ a comet at the first appearing, &c. _So_ did the blazing of my blush,” &c. “_Look how_ the world’s poor people are amazed, &c. _So_,” &c.-- Or thus: “_Even as_ an empty eagle sharpe by fast, &c.-- _Even so_,” &c.-- “_Like as_ a taper burning in the darke, &c. _So_,” &c.-- Such is the general style of the latter end of the sixteenth century; though sometimes (but very rarely) the form that Chatterton has used was also employed by Spenser and others. In the preceding century, if I am not much mistaken, it was wholly unknown.

But I have perhaps dwelled too long on this point. Every poetical reader will find instances of modern phraseology in almost every page of these spurious productions. I will only add, before I quit the subject of style, that it is observable, that throughout these poems we never find a noun in the plural number joined with a verb in the singular; an offence against grammar which every ancient poet, from the time of Chaucer to that of Shakespeare, has frequently committed, and from which Rowley, if such a poet had existed, would certainly not have been exempted.

Cursory Observations on the Poems Attributed to Thomas Rowley (1782) — Part 18