Massuet(419) brings forward, in support of the doctrine of transubstantiation, the fact that the Marcosians pretended, by magical rites, to effect a change of the wine into blood. As they professed to produce a substantial change, he infers that the Church must have really produced such a change. But the inference is far from being a sound one; for as magical rites are invented to pander to the appetite of the ignorant for something supernatural, so it is most probable that a pretender of this description, who wished to set up for something superior to the clergy, should profess to do something _more_ wonderful than they; that whereas they effected none but a mystical change, he should pretend to a literal one. And this no doubt is the history of transubstantiation. It is the attempt of unspiritual minds to raise the wonder of the sacred mysteries to the highest pitch, forgetful meanwhile of the spiritual objects of them. The doctrine is eminently a carnal doctrine.

Those scholastical discussions on the nature of justification with which we have become familiar had not arisen when Irenæus wrote, and consequently we cannot expect him to speak with the precision to which we are accustomed. Still there are some principal points upon which, simply following the Scriptures, he is _practically_ clear.

An Account of the Life and Writings of S. Irenæus, Bishop of Lyons — Part 73

He teaches, for instance, that men are not justified in themselves, but by the coming of Christ(420), and more explicitly, by the obedience of Christ(421); whence we may fairly conclude that he would place the _meritorious cause_ of justification in Christ: and as he connects justification with remission of sins(422), and remission of sins with the cross and death of Christ(423), he would no doubt trace our justification to the death of Christ on the cross.

An Account of the Life and Writings of S. Irenæus, Bishop of Lyons — Part 73

In the same general manner he teaches that faith justifies man(424), speaking particularly of Abraham, to whom he attributes faith in Christ. He appears likewise to express faith, in another passage, by attending to the light of Christ(425); but as the passage does not exist in the Greek, we cannot be quite certain what is its real meaning. Now although he says here that faith justifies, and elsewhere that our faith is our own(426), because it springs from our own will and choice, yet it is plain, from the previous paragraph, that he simply means that faith is the _qualification_ for justification.

An Account of the Life and Writings of S. Irenæus, Bishop of Lyons — Part 73