131. But sometimes the nature of a proposition is changed by means of amendments, with a view to its adoption in a sense the very opposite of what it was originally intended to bear. The following is a striking example of this mode of proceeding. In the house of commons, April 10, 1744, a resolution was moved, declaring, “That the issuing and paying to the Duke of Aremberg the sum of forty thousand pounds, sterling, to put the Austrian troops in motion in the year 1742, was a dangerous misapplication of public money, and destructive of the rights of parliament.” The object of this resolution was to censure the conduct of the ministers; and the friends of the ministry, being in a majority, might have voted directly, upon the motion and rejected it. But they preferred to turn it into a resolution approving of the conduct of ministers on the occasion referred to; and it was accordingly moved to amend, by leaving out the words “a dangerous misapplication,” etc., to the end of the motion, and inserting instead thereof the words, “necessary for putting the said troops in motion, and of great consequence to the common cause.” The amendment being adopted, it was resolved (reversing the original proposition) “That the issuing and paying to the Duke of Aremberg the sum of forty thousand pounds, to put the Austrian troops in motion, in the year 1742, was necessary for putting the said troops in motion, and of great consequence to the common cause.”

132. It is a mode of defeating a proposition, somewhat similar to that above mentioned, to carry out or extend the principle of it, by means of amendments, so as to show the inconvenience, absurdity, or danger of its adoption, with such evident clearness, that it becomes impossible for the assembly to agree to it. Thus, a motion having been made in the house of commons, “for copies of all the letters written by the lords of the admiralty to a certain officer in the navy,” it was moved to amend the motion by adding these words:—“which letters may contain orders, or be relative to orders, not executed, and still subsisting.” This amendment being adopted, the motion as amended was unanimously rejected.

Manual of Parliamentary Practice — Part 32

133. It will be seen, from the foregoing examples, that as the mover of a proposition is under no restriction as to embracing incongruous matters under the same motion; so, on the other hand, the assembly may engraft upon a motion, by way of amendment, matter which is not only incongruous with, but entirely opposed to, the motion as originally introduced; and, in legislative assemblies, it is not unusual to amend a bill by striking out all after the enacting clause, and inserting an entirely new bill; or to amend a resolution by striking out all after the words “Resolved that,” and inserting a proposition of a wholly different tenor.

Manual of Parliamentary Practice — Part 32