Our pioneer shall be a very plain and palpable illustration. Let A be a circle, containing within it X Y Z.
X Y and Z lie within the circle; and the question is, by what art or artifice--we might almost say by what sorcery--can they be transplanted out of it, without at the same time being made to overpass the limits of the sphere? There are just four conceivable answers to this question--answers illustrative of three great schools of philosophy, and of a fourth which is now fighting for existence.
1. One man will meet the difficulty boldly, and say--"X Y and Z certainly lie within the circle, but I believe they lie without it. _How_ this should be, I know not. I merely state what I conceive to be the fact. The _modus operandi_ is beyond my comprehension." This man's answer is contradictory, and will never do.
2. Another man will deny the possibility of the transference--"X Y and Z," he will say, "are generated within the circle in obedience to its own laws. They form part and parcel of the sphere; and every endeavour to regard them as endowed with an extrinsic existence, must end in the discomfiture of him who makes the attempt." This man declines giving any answer to the problem. We ask him _how_ X Y and can be projected beyond the circle without transgressing its limits; and he answers that they never are, and never can be so projected.
3. A third man will postulate as the cause of X Y Z a transcendent X Y Z--that is, a cause lying external to the sphere; and by referring the former to the latter, he will obtain for X Y X, not certainly a real externality, which is the thing wanted, but a _quasi-externality_, with which, as the best that is to be had, he will in all probability rest contented. "X Y and Z," he will say, "are projected, _as it were_, out of the circle." This answer leaves the question as much unsolved as ever. Or,
4. A fourth man (and we beg the reader's attention to this man's answer, for it forms the fulcrum or cardinal point on which our whole demonstration turns)--a fourth man will say, "If the circle could only be brought _within itself_, so--
then the difficulty would disappear--the problem would be completely solved. X Y Z must now of necessity fall as extrinsic to the circle A; and this, too, (which is the material part of the solution,) without the limits of the circle A being overstepped."