Peny is a hardy knyght, Peny is mekyl of myght, Peny of wrong, he makyt ryght In every cuntré qwer he goo. [Go bet, etc.]
Ritson quotes a companion poem from ‘a MS. of the 13th or 14th century, in the library of Berne’:—
Denier fait cortois de vilain, Denier fait de malade sain, Denier sorprent le monde a plain, Tot est en son commandement.
And no doubt he is right in supposing that these variants (together with the Archpriest’s version) come from _Dom Argent_, a story—not, as Ritson thought, a _fableau_—given in extract by Le Grand d’Aussy in the third volume of the _Fabliaux, Contes, Fables et Romans du XII^e et du XIII^e siècle_ published in 1829. Once more, take the story of the abstemious hermit who once got drunk, went from bad to worse, and finally fell into the hangman’s hands. As Wolf points out, this episode was introduced earlier in the _Libro de Apolonio_; but the Archpriest develops it more fully, amalgamating the tale of _L’Eremite qui s’enyvra_ with _L’Ermyte que le diable conchia du coc et de la geline_. Lastly, the combat between Don Carnal and Doña Quaresma is most brilliantly adapted from the _Bataille de Karesme et de Charnage_:—
Seignor, ge ne vos quier celer, Uns fablel vueil renoveler Qui lonc tens a esté perdus: Onques mais Rois, ne Quens, ne Dus N’oïrent de millor estoire, Par ce l’ai-ge mis en mémoire.
But the Archpriest’s genial reconstruction outdoes the original at every point. And this is even more emphatically true of _Pamphilus de Amore_, which also no doubt, like the _fableaux_ and _contes_, drifted into Spain from France. At moments Juan Ruiz is content to be an admirable translator. Read, for instance, what Pamphilus says to Galatea in the First Act (sc. iv.) of the Latin play—
Alterius villa mea neptis mille salutes Per me mandavit officiumque tibi: Hec te cognoscit dictis et nomine tantum, Et te, si locus est, ipsa videre cupit—
and compare it with Don Melón’s address to Doña Endrina in the _Libro de buen amor_:—
Señora, la mj sobrina, que en toledo seya, se vos encomjenda mucho, mjll saludes vos enbya; sy ovies lugar e tienpo, por quanto de vos oya, desea vos mucho ver e conosçer vos querria.
And you will find from thirty to forty points of resemblance duly noted in Sr. Puyol y Alonso’s valuable study. But what does it matter if a more microscopic scrutiny reveals a hundred parallelisms? Ruiz proceeds as Shakespeare proceeded after him. He picks up waste scraps of base metal from a dunghill, and by his wonder-working touch transforms them into gold. He breathes life into the ghostly abstractions of the pseudonymous Auvergnat, creates a man and a woman in the stress of irresistible passion, and evokes a dramatic atmosphere. You read _Pamphilus de Amore_: you find it dull when it is not licentious, and you most often find it both dull and licentious at the same time. Not a solitary character, not a single happy line, not one memorable phrase remains with you to redeem its tedious pruriency. The Archpriest’s two lovers are unforgettable: they are not saints—far from it!—but they are human in their weakness, and in their downfall they are the sympathetic victims of disaster. And the vitality of the other personage in this concentrated narrative of illicit love is proved by its persistence in literature. A feminine Tartufe, with a dangerous subtlety and perverse enjoyment of immorality for its own sake, Trotaconventos is the ancestress of Celestina, of Regnier’s Macette, and of the hideous old nurse in _Romeo and Juliet_. Turn to the end of the _Libro de buen amor_, and observe the predatory figure of Don Furón: he, too, is unforgettable as the model of the ravenous fine gentleman who condescended to share Lazarillo’s plate of trotters. What matter if the Archpriest lays hands on a _fableau_, or a _conte_, or a wearisome piece of lubricity ‘veiled in the obscurity of a learned language’? What matter if he pilfers from the _Libro de Alixandre_, or steals an idea from the _Roman de la Rose_? He makes his finds his own by right of conquest, like Catullus or Virgil before him, like Shakespeare and Molière after him.