A report issued this week alleges that the supply chain serving the global automobile industry is deeply intertwined with companies that either make direct use of forced labor in China's Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, or that purchase raw materials and other products from companies that do.
Written by a team of researchers at Sheffield Hallam University in the United Kingdom, the report, titled alleges that most auto manufacturers in the world use parts that are sourced either directly or indirectly from the Xinjiang region, and urges both carmakers and governments around the world to sever those connections.
"[P]ractically every major traditional automotive and electric vehicle manufacturer has significant exposure to forced labor in the Uyghur Region," the report finds. "The auto industry cannot wait another day to trace their supply chains back to the raw materials. To do anything short of full tracing would be an enormous legal, ethical, and reputational risk."
Major U.S. automakers did not immediately respond to the report. China has long denied the existence of forced labor in Xinjiang amid substantial evidence backing accusations by the United Nations, major human rights groups and Western countries.
In sometimes meticulous detail, the report illustrates the way in which specific automobile elements — tires, seat cushions, batteries, electronic components and more — can be traced to raw materials extracted in Xinjiang, companies doing business in Xinjiang, or companies that have participated in a Chinese government program through which workers from Xinjiang are forcibly relocated to other parts of China and required to work there.
By documenting the connection of automobile components to Xinjiang, the report raises questions about whether car manufacturers are in compliance with a U.S. law, the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (UFLPA).
VOA could not independently confirm all of the data in the report, but experts who have reviewed it say that it appears to present a clear picture of an automobile supply chain deeply reliant on components tied to Xinjiang.
Cullen Hendrix, a nonresident senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, said the report is "staggering in its scope." He added, "It tells a complicated story incredibly well, and in a compelling, straightforward fashion. One doesn't have to be a supply chain guru to see the challenges that this creates for the U.S. automotive industry and ultimately for the global automotive industry, at least the segment of it that would like to be present in the U.S. market."
The report carries clear implications for other industries as well. Many of the car components linked to Xinjiang, including steel, copper, aluminum and silicon, are basic inputs for myriad other manufacturing sectors.
Professor Laura Murphy, one of the authors of the report, pressed that point in an email exchange with VOA, writing, "It is becoming ever more apparent that the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act is urgently necessary. We hope that this report is a wake-up call not only to the automotive industry but to all manufacturers sourcing steel or aluminum or copper or lithium or practically anything else from China. Why wait for us to produce another report? The time is now for companies to trace their supply chains to the raw materials."
The UFLPA, which was signed into law by President Joe Biden in December of 2021 and took effect in June of this year, creates what is known as a "rebuttable presumption" that anything imported to the U.S. that originates wholly or partly in Xinjiang is the product of forced labor.
That means it is legal for the U.S. to import only those items for which the importer presents "clear and convincing evidence" the product hasn't been made with forced labor. Absent that proof, imported goods are subject to seizure by U.S. Customs and Border Protection authorities.
When the law took effect, it was widely expected to have the greatest impact on a few specific industries. For example, Xinjiang is a major producer of both cotton and the polysilicon used in solar panels, so the clothing and solar industries had braced for significant disruption.
However, the report suggests that far more industries may be in peril.