ERROR to the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York; in which court Fiske sued Smythe, collector, in December, 1868, to recover money alleged to have been illegally exacted by the said defendant, as collector, for duties upon imports.

The things in respect to which the duties were exacted were silk neck-ties, imported in October, 1868.

Smythe v. Fiske

The collector had exacted a duty of 60 per cent. upon them, against the payment of which the defendant protested, because, as he alleged, silk neck-ties were liable to a duty of but 35 per cent.

Smythe v. Fiske

It was shown in evidence that the neck-ties in question were made of silk, folded and ironed, turned over and pressed by hand, the ends being afterwards stitched; that they were known in trade and commerce as 'silk ties,' and never as 'scarfs' or as articles of ready-made clothing.

Smythe v. Fiske

The true decision of the question depended upon the right interpretation of certain acts of Congress, referred to and relied on by the two parties respectively. The enactments referred to are as follows:

The twentieth section of an act of August 30th, 1842, after laying duties on a large number of enumerated articles, thus enacted:

'There shall be paid on every non-enumerated article which bears a similitude, either in material, quality, texture, or the use to which it may be applied, to any enumerated article chargeable with duty, the same rate of duty which is charged on the article which it most resembles in the particulars mentioned. If any non-enumerated article resembles equally two or more enumerated articles on which different rates of duty are chargeable, there shall be paid on such article the rate of duty chargeable on the article it resembles paying the highest duty; and on all articles manufactured from two or more materials, the duty shall be assessed at the highest rate at which any of its component parts may be chargeable.'

An act of July 30th, 1846, imposed a duty of 30 per cent. ad valorem upon the articles of merchandise specified in a schedule annexed to it, and embracing among other things,

Articles worn by men, women, or children, of whatever materials composed, made up or made wholly or in part by hand, not otherwise provided for.'

An act of May 2d, 1861, imposed a duty of 30 per cent. upon the articles therein enumerated. Among them were 'articles worn by men,' &c., as specified in the act of 1846, and described in the same terms. Another section enacted that upon certain specified articles of silk (neck-ties not being among them), and upon

`

'All other manufactures of silk or of which silk shall be the component material of chief value, a duty of 30 per cent. ad valorem shall be paid.'By an act of July 14th, 1862, an additional duty of 5 per cent. was imposed upon 'articles worn by men,' &c., repeating the language of the act of 1846 in describing them.

Up to this date it seemed to be admitted that silk neckties would pay but 30 or 35 per cent. at most. However, on the 30th July, 1864, Congress passed another act, an act entitled 'An act to increase duties on imports, and for other purposes.'

This act, though not in substitution of all prior acts laying duties on imports, was, nevertheless, an act which went over a great field of duties on imports, and laid a vast number of duties in lieu of former ones. It covered sixteen pages of the statute-book, and had in it twenty-nine sec ions.

Teas, sugar, confectionery, molasses, brandy, spirits, cordials, liquors, bay rum, wines, ale, porter, beer, cigars, snuff, tobacco, iron, tin, steel, copper, lead, and zinc of many different sorts and differently fabricated; diamonds, wool, and manufactures of wool, sheepskin, carpets and carpeting, women's dress goods, shirts, drawers, hosiery, manufactures of worsted and cotton, cotton velvet, linens, and manufactures of flax, spun silk, earthenware, stoneware, and china, slates, clay, glass, a large variety of drugs, bristles, lemons, pepper, salt, books, gunpowder, mineral water, marble, soap, and several other articles were all affected by its provisions.

This act of July 30th, 1864, by its eighth section thus enacted:

'SECTION 8. In lieu of the duties heretofore imposed by law, on the articles hereinafter mentioned, there shall be levied, collected, and paid on the goods, wares, and merchandise enumerated and provided for in this section, imported from foreign countries, the following duties and the rates of duty, that is to say—