“The whole right of the conqueror comes from that just self-defence which comprehends the maintenance and prosecution of his rights. When, therefore, he has entirely subdued a hostile nation, he may undoubtedly, in the first place, do himself justice with regard to that which gave rise to the war, and indemnify himself for the expenses and damages it has caused him; he may, according to the exigency of the case, impose penalties upon the conquered nation by way of example; he may even, if prudence require, _render it incapable of doing harm so easily in future_.”[259]

The offending party, when conquered, may be rendered incapable of doing harm so easily in future. This is according to natural justice. Then again the same familiar authority says:--

Charles Sumner; his complete works, volume 13 (of 20) — Part 211

“If the inhabitants have been personally guilty of any criminal attempt against the conqueror, _he may by way of punishment deprive them of their rights and franchises_. This, again, he may do, if the inhabitants have taken up arms against him and thus directly rendered themselves his enemies. He then owes them nothing more than what is due from a humane and equitable conqueror to subjugated enemies.”[260]

Charles Sumner; his complete works, volume 13 (of 20) — Part 211

Surely, out of this ample power Congress cannot hesitate in requiring justice to the wards and allies of the Republic through whom the Rebellion was crushed, especially when without justice to them security in the future is nothing but a mockery and a phantasmagoria.

Charles Sumner; his complete works, volume 13 (of 20) — Part 211

3. From these sources of power I pass to that other found in _the constitutional obligation to guaranty to every State of the Union a republican form of government_. Here is the text:--

“The United States shall guaranty to every State in this Union a republican form of government.”

This obligation is peremptory, and not discretionary. It is _shall_, and not _may_. The United States _must_ do it. Of course, in executing the guaranty, you must affix a meaning to the term “republican form of government.” To do this I have in this debate endeavored to show the essential principles our fathers had at heart when they founded the Republic. I shall not weary you again with the historic statement. It is enough, if I present the conclusion. According to the Fathers, all men are equal in rights, and, as corollaries from this truth, all just government is founded on the consent of the governed, and taxation without representation is tyranny. Such was their idea of a republican government.