Every Verb involves in it the force of the _copula_. It combines the marking powers of an _adjective_, and of the _copula_; and all Verbs may be resolved into those elements. Thus, "John walks," is the same with "John is walking." Verbs, therefore, are attributives, of the same nature as adjectives, only with additional connotative powers; and they cut smaller classes out of larger, in the manner of adjectives. Thus "John walks," is an expression, the same in import as the Predication "John is a walking man;" and, walking men, standing men, running men, lying men, are all sub-species of the Species Man.

The same unhappy duplicity of meaning, which is incurred by using the _Substantive_ Verb as the _copula_ in Predication, is inflicted on _other_ Verbs, in that part of their marking power by which they exhibit the connection between the two terms of a Predication.

Analysis of the Phenomena of the Human Mind — Part 121

The _copula_, included in Verbs, is not the PURE _copula_, { 177} but the ACTUAL _copula_; the _copula_ familiar and in constant use; namely, the Substantive Verb. From this it results, that whatever the peculiar attribute, which is predicated by means of any verb, EXISTENCE is always predicated along with it. Thus, when I say "John walks," which is equivalent to "John is walking," I predicate both existence, and walking, of John. When I say, "Caliban existed not," which is the same as "Caliban was not existing," I predicate both existence, and non-existence, of the imaginary being Caliban. By the two first words of the Predication, "Caliban was," existence is predicated of him; by the addition of the compound term "not existing," the opposite is predicated of him.

Analysis of the Phenomena of the Human Mind — Part 121

The instances, in which the more complicated formations of the mind are the subjects of this double Predication, are those which, from the importance of their consequences, deserve the greatest degree of attention. Thus, when we say "virtue exalts," both _existing_, and _exalting_, are predicated of virtue. When we say that "passion impels," both _existence_, and _impulsion_, are predicated of passion. When we say that "Time generates," and "Space contains all things," we affirm _existence_ of space and time, by the same expression by which we affirm of the one, that it generates; of the other, that it contains. This constancy of Predication, forcing the same constancy in the junction of the ideas, furnishes a remarkable instance of that important case of association, of which we took notice above, where, by frequency of association, two ideas become so joined, that the one constantly rises, and cannot be prevented from rising, in combination with the other. Thus it is, { 178} that Time forces itself upon us as an _object_. So it is with Space. We cannot think of Space, we cannot think of Time, without thinking of them as existent. With the ideas of space and time, the idea of EXISTENCE, as it is predicated of objects, is so associated, by the use of the Substantive Verb as the _copula_ in predication, that we cannot disjoin them. The same would have been the case with Chance, and Fate, and Nature; if our religious education did not counteract the association. It was precisely the same, among the Greeks and Romans, whose religious education had not that effect.[53] [54]

Analysis of the Phenomena of the Human Mind — Part 121