“I have it in my heart to wish that this book might have the vogue that _Little Women_ had. The simple, beautiful story is worth a thousand sermons and treatises on the best way of rearing and training a family.”

The _Christian Herald_ enters many homes and Margaret E. Sangster was read by many thousands. There is no way of measuring the direct and indirect influence of such praise as she uttered. It is very great. But this was in 1907. The year following the appearance of _A daughter of the Rich_, Miss Waller’s third book, _The Wood-Carver of ’Lympus_, came along.

The Women Who Make Our Novels — Part 205

Books have curious fates. Gene Stratton-Porter’s _Freckles_ took three years to find its audience. A fine novel by St. John G. Ervine, _Changing Winds_, was published, had the expected sale and died; remained dead for about a year and then suddenly began selling again! In the case of a textbook such a phenomenon can always be traced to some simple explanation. For example, W. J. Henderson wrote a condensed treatise called _Elements of Navigation_ which sold desultorily for years, the sales slowly declining. Came the Great War. The United States undertook to create a merchant marine. Thousands of men had to be trained to navigate merchant ships. Mr. Henderson’s book sold like hot cakes, was reprinted; was revised and pretty well rewritten; sold faster than fiction!

The Women Who Make Our Novels — Part 205

In the case of a novel a “resurrection” is seldom quite explicable. It is matter for conjecture what “brought back” _Changing Winds_. Now _The Wood-Carver of ’Lympus_ was not a book that rose from the dead, but a book that almost never lived; that is to say, it was six months before it achieved popular success. Once “alive” it has ever since remained so. Seven years after publication the _twenty-eighth_ edition was published. It is unnecessary to say more.

The Women Who Make Our Novels — Part 205

The catalogue of the American Library Association, a conscientious publication if ever there was one, describes this book concisely: “Scene in the Green Mountains. An ambitious farmer crippled in early manhood finds interests in the outside world through a chance acquaintance and becomes a wood-carver of renown.” There you are; see what conscientiousness can accomplish! All the charm, all the wistfulness, all the magic of hope and aspiration, and the triumph of achievement, which make this novel the beloved tale it is--stripped away! “An ambitious farmer crippled in early manhood....” The librarians are not to blame, either. It is their business to outline concisely.... Whereas fiction is no matter of outlines but, like life, a thing of coloring, perspective, the glint of an eye, the shadowed corner of a smiling mouth. Fiction cannot be done in black and white; those who, under the label of “realism,” essay the task, invariably fail.