M. E. M. de Vogüé has other views. To him _Robinson Crusoe_ is “un bon traité de psychologie historique sur un peuple,”—an historic psychology of the English race.—_Histoire et Poésie_, p. 194.
_Works_, Hartford, 1889, I. 213 f. Essay on Wordsworth, etc. Bruchmann, in his excellent _Poetik_, Berlin, 1898, gives up the attempt to mark off poetry from prose, speaks of a “neutral ground,” and then defines poetry as “Steigerung durch Form und Inhalt; _die Form ist Gesang, Rhythmus, Reim_” (p. 53). What more could the defender of rhythm ask as working test?

When only one-and-twenty. _Meditationes Philosophicae de Nonnullis ad Poema Pertinentibus_, 1735.

_Jugendschriften F. Schl._, ed. Minor, I. 99; a study of Greek poetry.

_Athenæum_, III. 87 f., in Talks about Poetry.
_Problèmes de l’Esthétique Contemporaine_, p. 172.
_Ibid._, p. 150,—“ce poëte sans le rhythme.”
Gautier, too, thought that Flaubert had “invented a new rhythm” in prose, and described it; see the report of this, _Journal des Goncourt_, 1862, January 1. But later, in the same journal (1876, February 24), Goncourt refers all this sort of thing to Chateaubriand: “sa belle prose poétique, _mère et nourrice de toutes les proses colorées de l’heure actuelle_....”
_L’Art au Point de Vue Sociologique_, p. 312.
“Briefe über Poesie, Sylbenmaas und Sprache,” first in Schiller’s _Horen_, reprinted in the _Charakteristiken und Critiken_, I. 318 ff.; _Werke_, ed. Böcking, VII. 98 ff.
_Wettstreit der Sprachen_, Böcking, VII. 199.
_Etwas über William Shakspere_, Böcking, VII. 55.
See below, p. 134, for a still more noteworthy and yet quite unnoticed change of front made by Schlegel in the article of folksong.
It must be said for Schlegel that he is here—so, at least, it seems—merely clearing the way for his historical and “genetic” study of the art, and so is bound to have no hampering dogma, no _parti pris_ in the case.
Notably that division of _epopœia_, “which imitates by words alone or by verse.” The question is whether Aristotle meant in the first case “words without metre” or “words without music.” See Twining’s fourth note.—It has been pointed out that nowhere in the fragment does Aristotle essay a formal definition of poetry.





