Russian Energy Minister Aleksandr Novak told journalists in Moscow on June 13 that Ukraine is not ready to conclude a new natural gas transmission contract with Russia on terms required by the European Union. Novak was referring to the ongoing reforms of Ukraine’s gas sector in lieu of the EU’s Third Energy Package, which are not completed.
The Russian energy minister was speaking at a press briefing after his talks with European Commission Vice President Maroš Šefčovič about the continuation of natural through Ukraine after the current agreement between Kyiv and Moscow expires at the end of 2019.
The European Commission has facilitated several rounds of between Ukraine and Russia aimed at ensuring the uninterrupted transit of natural gas from Russia to Europe via Ukraine.
"Ukraine today is not yet ready, from the point of view of changes to the existing legislation, to ensure the conclusion of the contract on terms used in Europe,” . “In fact, the easiest option is to extend the existing contract, which was offered to the Ukrainian side."
Novak’s claim is false.
An American lawyer, Myron B. Rabij, a partner at McCarter & English, told Polygraph.info that Novak was referring to the expected unbundling of the Ukrainian gas transmission system -- i.e., separating the ownership from the operation of the gas network. The and subsequent appointment of an independent transmission system operator is critical to the Ukrainian gas sector reforms.
Ukraine is a member of the European Energy Community and has started restructuring its energy sector in compliance with EU’s energy and competition regulations. The country to implement fully the Third Energy Package under the Protocol of Accession to the EnergyCommunityTreaty, signed in 2010 and ratified by the Verkhovna Rada.
But the process of unbundling and creating a transmission system operator (TSO), as required by the EU’s Third Energy Package, has been slow, according to Energy Community Secretariat Director .
At the same time, “Gazprom is saying that it wants to sign a contract not with Naftogaz Ukraine, but with a certified TSO that does not exist, while they are trying to quickly build gas pipelines bypassing Ukraine - TurkStream and Nord Stream 2,” Kopač said at the annual conference in Amsterdam last month.
“Russia’s question is in respect to unbundling,” Rabij said. “Namely, with whom is Russia signing an agreement – is it Naftogaz or is it an unbundled entity that is going to sign the agreement on January 1, 2020? It is an important question of how to make the contract legally binding if the unbundling takes place six months from now.”
Rabij said this concern is unsubstantiated: “What Russia says, however, is a nonsense because you can take care of it with one paragraph in the future contract that would stipulate that the new unbundled entity would assume all responsibilities outlined in the agreement.”
Furthermore, Rabij noted that international contracts signed by Ukrainian state-owned energy companies are compatible with the requirements, coordinated with the European Commission and valid before European arbitration bodies. This means that if a contracting body, such as Naftogaz Ukraine, needs to be restructured after a new agreement with Gazprom is signed, that agreement would contain provisions transferring all contractual responsibilities to the new transmission system operator.
Currently, Russia exports half of its gas to Europe and Turkey . If both Nord Stream 2 and TurkStream are completed, Russia will stop using the or will need it only at peak season for small volumes of gas.
The EU has been negotiating with Moscow and Kyiv to make sure that gas supplies to Europe continue uninterrupted after December 2019. Novak Šefčovič that “Russia is taking a constructive position; it is ready to continue gas transit through Ukraine and ensure supplies to European customers. We are ready for the extension of the contract under the existing terms.”
Ambassador Richard Morningstar, former Special Envoy of the U.S. Secretary of State for Eurasian Energy, told Polygraph.info: “I know that the EU is very much committed to working with Ukraine and working with Russia to come to an appropriate agreement. If there is a will to make a deal between the two parties, a deal can be made.”
But the Russian energy minister only proposed extending the current contract between Gazprom and Naftogaz Ukraine, instead of signing a new long-term agreement. This would allow Russia to commit to just a short-term extension and if Nord Stream 2 and TurkStream become operational.