Appendix II.

Note on Section 69, Page 149.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume XI/The Commonitory of Vincent of Lerins/Appendix II

That Vincentius had Augustine and his adherents in view

in this description will hardly be doubted by any one who will compare

it with the following extracts, the first from Prosper’s letter to

Augustine, giving him an account of the complaints made against his doctrine by the Massilian clergy; the second from St. Augustine’s treatise, “De dono Perseveranti ” written in consequence of it.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume XI/The Commonitory of Vincent of Lerins/Appendix II

“Si quis interroget quempiam

hæreticorum sibi talia persuadentem, Unde probas, unde doces quod

Ecclesiæ Catholicæ universalem et antiquam fidem dimittere

debeam? Statum ille, ‘Scriptum est enim,’ et continuo mille testimonia, mille exempla, mille auctoritates parat de Lege, de Psalmis, de Apostolis, de Prophetis, quibus, novo et malo more interpretatis, ex arce Catholica in hæreseos barathrum infelix anima præcipitetur. Audent enim polliceri et docere, quod in Ecclesia sua, id est, in communionis suæ conventiculo, magna et specialis ac plane personalis quædam sit Dei gratia, adeo ut sine ullo labore, sine ullo studio, sine ulla industria, etiamsi nec petant, nec quærant, nec pulsent, quicunque illi ad numerum suum pertinent, tamen ita divinitus dispensentur, ut, angelicis evecti manibus, id est, angelica protectione servati, nunquam possint offendere ad lapidem pedem suum, id est, nunquam scandalizari.”

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume XI/The Commonitory of Vincent of Lerins/Appendix II

“The Massilian clergy complain,” he says, “Romoveri omnem industriam, tollique virtutes, si Dei constitutio humanus præveniat voluntates.” § 3.

Then referring to the teaching of the Massilians

themselves, Prosper continues,

“Ad conditionem hanc velint uniuscujusque

hominis pertinere, ut ad cognitionem Dei et ad obedientiam mandatorum

Ejus possit suam dirigere voluntatem, et ad hanc gratiam qua in Christo

renascimur pervenire, per naturalem scilicet facultatem, petendo, quærendo, pulsando.”

Referring to the line of argument pursued by

himself and others of Augustine’s friends and the Massilian way

of dealing with it, he says, “Et cum contra eos Scripta

Beatitudinis tuæ validissimis et innumeris testimoniis Divinarum Scriptuarum instructa proferimus,…obstinationem suam vetustate defendunt.” § 3.

St. Augustine replies to Prosper not in an ordinary

letter, but in two short Treatises, which must have been written

immediately afters its receipt, for he died in August 430, the first

entitled “De Prædestinatione Sanctorum,” the second

“De Dono Perseverantiæ.”

The following extract is from the latter:

“Attendant ergo quomodo falluntur qui putant

Esse a nobis, non dari nobis, ut petamus, quæramus, pulsemus. Et hoc esse, dicunt, quod gratia præceditur merito nostro, ut sequatur illa cum accipimus petentes, et invenimus quærentes, aperiturque pulsantibus. Nec volunt intelligere etiam hoc divini muneris esse ut oremus, hoc est, petamus, quæramus, atque pulsamus.”—De Dono Persev. c. 23, § 64.

Vincentius’s language is in keeping with

that of others of St. Augustine’s opponents, as Cassian and

Faustus, extracts from whom are given by Noris; only, as he observes, while Vincentius uses the term “heresy” of the doctrine impugned,—they are content to use the milder term “error.”—Histor. Pelag. p. 246.

Footnotes