Before coming to the merits we dispose of an objection to the jurisdiction.
The appeal was prosecuted under clause (b) 1 of § 25 of the bankrupt act of July 1, 1898 (30 Stat. at L. 553, chap. 541, U.S.C.omp. Stat. 1901, p. 3432), providing that from any final decision of a court of appeals, allowing or rejecting a claim under the act, an appeal may be had 'where the amount in controversy exceeds the sum of two thousand dollars, and the question involved is one which might have been taken on appeal or writ of error from the highest court of a state to the Supreme Court of the United States.'
The provision of the Revised Statutes regulating the revision of judgments and decrees of state courts, which is relied upon, in conjunction with the portion of a decision in the suit can be had, 'where any of § 709 (U.S.C.omp. Stat. 1901, p. 575) which authorizes the re-examination of a final judgment or decree in any suit in the highest court of a state in which a decision in the suit can be had, 'shere any title, right, privilege, or immunity is claimed under . . . any . . . statute of . . . the United States, and the decision is against the title, right, privilege, or immunity specially set up or claimed, by either party, under such . . . statute, . . .'
The appellee does not question that this appeal is from a decree rejecting a claim, within the meaning of the statute, and that the requisite jurisdictional amount is involved, but the particular objection urged is that a right was not claimed under an act of Congress, nor was a right of that nature denied by the lower courts.
The objection is not tenable. It clearly appears from the record that in the claim filed on behalf of the tie company there was embodied, as an integral part thereof, as a proper credit or set-off, the sum retained from the wages of employees for supplies furnished by the bankrupt, and the rejection of the claim was based upon the denial of the right to set-off. As the right of set-off is controlled by the provisions of § 68 of the bankrupt act, the assertion of such a right, in a proceeding in bankruptcy, as was the case here, is necessarily based upon those provisions of the act of Congress, and in this case the construction of such statutory provision was undoubtedly involved. That the circuit court of appeals understood that reliance was had by the tie company upon the set-off clauses of the act is shown by its opinion, where, after sustaining the claim of the trustees that the credits in question constituted a preference, it prefaced a particular discussion of the contention as to a right of set-off by the following statement:
'Finally, it is said that this $2,210.73 was a credit to Harrison, and that the company should be permitted to set it off against his debt to it, and should be allowed to prove its claim for the balance remaining without restriction, on the ground that these claims were mutual debts and credits under § 68 of the bankrupt law.'
The record, we think, sufficiently presented a claim of Federal right (Home for Incurables v. New York, 187 U.S. 157, 47 L. ed. 117, 23 Sup. Ct. Rep. 84), and the objection to the jurisdiction is therefore overruled.
Passing to the merits of the controversy—
We must, at the outset, in the light of the facts found below, determine the exact relation existing between the bankrupt and the tie company, in order to fix the true import of the transactions by which the tie company, in making its claim against the bankrupt estate, asserted a right to retain and set off the sums which, in its proof of claim, it described as 'deductions from pay rolls.'