In a second paper Elenkin records one clear instance of a haustorium entering an algal cell, and says he found some evidence of hyphal branches penetrating otherwise uninjured gonidia, round holes being visible in their outer wall, but he holds that it is the cell-wall of the alga that is mainly dissolved by the ferment and then used as food by the hyphae.
No allowance has been made by Elenkin for the normal wasting common to all organic beings: the lichen fungus is continually being renewed, especially in the cortical structures, and the alga must also be subject to change. He[229] claims, nevertheless, that his observations have proved that the one symbiont is always preying on the other, either as a parasite or as a saprophyte. He has likened the conception of symbiosis to that of a balance between two organisms, “a moveable equilibrium of the symbionts.” If, he says, we could conceive a state where the conditions of life would be equally favourable for both partners there would be true mutualism, but in practice one only is favoured and gains the upper hand, using its advantage to prey on the other. Unless the balance is redressed, the complete destruction of the weaker is certain, and is followed in time by the death of the stronger. The fungus being the dominant partner, the balance, he considers, is tipped in its favour.
Elenkin’s conclusions are not borne out by the long continued and healthy life of the lichen. There is no record of either symbiont having succumbed to the other, and the alga, when set free, is unchanged and able to resume its normal development. Without the alga the fungus cannot form the ascigerous fruit. Is that because as a parasite within the lichen it has degenerated past recovery, or has it become so adapted to symbiosis that in saprophytic conditions it fails to develop?
Another Russian lichenologist, U. N. Danilov[230], records results which would seem to support the theory of parasitism. He found that from the clasping hyphae minute haustoria were produced, which penetrate the algal cell-wall, and branch when within the outer membrane, thus forming a delicate network over the plasma; secondary haustoria arising from this network protrude into the interior and rob the cell-contents. He observed gonidia filled with well-developed hyphae and these, after having exhausted one cell, travel onwards to others. Some gonidia under the influence of the fungus had become deformed and were finally killed. As a proof of this latter statement he adduces the presence in the thallus of some gonidia containing shrivelled protoplasm, of others entirely empty. He considers, as further evidence in favour of parasitism, the finding of empty membranes as well as of colourless gonidia filled with the hyphal network. This description hardly tallies with the usual healthy appearance of the gonidial zone in the normal thallus, and it has been suggested that where the fungus filled the algal cell, it was as a saprophyte preying on dead material.