The youngest larval stages are those which are of the most importance for revealing the phyletic development, because they make us acquainted with the markings of the progenitors of the existing species. For these investigations it is therefore in the first place necessary to obtain fertile eggs. Female _Sphingidæ_, however, do not generally lay eggs in confinement,[66] or at most only a very small number. In the case of many species (_Deilephila Galii_, _D. Lineata_, _D. Vespertilio_, _D. Hippophaës_) I have for this reason unfortunately been unable to observe the entire development, and such observations would in all probability have given especially valuable information.

I was certainly successful in finding the young larvæ of some of the above as well as of other species on their food-plants, but even in the most favourable instances only individuals of the second stage and generally older. When, however, notwithstanding this imperfection of the materials, and in spite of the important gaps thus inevitably caused in these series of observations, it has nevertheless been possible to form a picture, on the whole tolerably complete, of the phyletic development of the Sphinx-markings, this well indicates what a fertile field is offered by the investigation of this subject, and will, I trust, furnish an inducement to others, not only to fill up the various gaps in the small family of the _Sphingidæ_, but also to treat other Lepidopterous families in a similar manner. Such an investigation of the _Papilionidæ_ appears to me to be especially desirable; not only of the few European but also of the American and Indian species. We know practically nothing, of the youngest stages of the _Papilio_ larvæ from this point of view. No entomological work gives any description of the form and marking of the newly hatched larvæ, even in the case of our commonest species (_Papilio Machaon_ and _P. Podalirius_), and I believe that I do not go too far when I assert that up to the present time nobody has observed them at this early stage.[67] When, however, we consider that in these young caterpillars we have preserved to us the parent-form, extinct for centuries, of the existing species of _Papilio_, it must assuredly be of the greatest interest to become accurately acquainted with them, to compare them with the earliest stages of allied species, and to follow the gradual divergence of the succeeding stages in different directions, thus forming a picture of the phyletic development of an evolving group. In the course of such observations numerous collateral results would doubtless come out. Investigations of this kind, whether conducted on this or on any other group, would, above all, show the true systematic affinities of the forms, _i.e._, their _genealogical_ affinities, and that in a better way than could be shown by the morphology of the perfect insects or the adult caterpillars alone. If I am diffident in founding these conclusions upon the development of the Sphinx-markings treated of in the present essay, this arises entirely from a knowledge of the imperfections in the basis of facts. If however, through the united labours of many investigators, the individual development of all the species of _Sphingidæ_ now existing should at some future period be clearly laid before us, we should then not only have arrived at a knowledge of the relative ages of the different species, genera and families, but we should also arrive at an explanation of the nature of their affinities.

Studies in the Theory of Descent, Volume I (of 2) — Part 97