=12. REDUCTION OF THE DISJUNCTIVE ARGUMENT TO THE HYPOTHETICAL AND THEN TO THE CATEGORICAL.=

It would seem that the laws of the disjunctive contradict those of the categorical syllogism; for we apparently derive from two affirmatives a negative conclusion, and we also derive an affirmative conclusion when one premise is negative. This objection is seen to be nugatory when the disjunctive is reduced to the categorical form. The reduction involves the two steps of first changing the disjunctive to the hypothetical form and then to the categorical form. The following illustrations will suffice to make the matter clear:

A Class Room Logic — Part 168

(1) _Disjunctive._ A is either B or C A is B ∴ A is not C

A Class Room Logic — Part 168

_Hypothetical._ If A is B, then A is not C A is B ∴ A is not C

A Class Room Logic — Part 168

_Categorical._ The case of A being B is the case of A not being C In this case A is B ∴ A is not C

(2) _Disjunctive._ The defendant is either guilty or innocent; He is not innocent, ∴ He is guilty.

_Hypothetical._ If the defendant is guilty, then he is not innocent; But he is guilty, ∴ He is not innocent.

_Categorical._ The case of the defendant being guilty is the case of the defendant not being innocent, In this case the defendant is guilty, ∴ In this case the defendant is not innocent.

The majority of us are acquainted with the dilemma as related to the activities of life. One is in a dilemma when there are two courses open to him but neither is particularly enticing. One is placed in a dilemma when he is forced to choose the lesser of two evils. For example, one may, without the proper equipment, be overtaken by a heavy rain storm; he seeks the shelter of a wayside shed; the rain continues so that he is forced either to miss his train, or to endure the discomfort of a drenching. Thus the logical dilemma limits one to a choice between alternatives, either one of which might well be avoided.

_The dilemma is a syllogism in which the major premise consists of two or more hypothetical propositions, while the minor premise is a disjunctive proposition._

It being a combination of hypothetical and disjunctive propositions the dilemma is sometimes appropriately referred to as the “hypothetico-disjunctive” argument. The order of the premises is indifferent, yet it seems to be more natural to use the hypothetical first; thus the definition.