But when we have shown that the doctrine of Divine immanence does not, as some of its advocates would have us believe, swallow up human individuality--a subject to which we shall return--we are faced with yet another difficulty. The question is asked--again, quite naturally and inevitably--In what sense can we speak of God as immanent in the inorganic world? How, _e.g._, does a stone embody or express His essence?--and yet, if it is not somehow a manifestation of Him, what is this cold, lifeless, ponderable substance we call a stone? Nor do matters grow simpler when we ascend in the scale: we may trace the immanent Deity in all that is good and fair in nature, in all its smiling and beneficent moods--but what of nature's uglinesses and cruelties? Is God expressing Himself in the ferocity of the tiger, the poisonous malice of the cobra, the greed of every unclean carrion-bird? If He is such as religion represents Him, how can He be present in these? We may quote with rapture the familiar lines in which the poet tells us:--

I have felt A presence that disturbs me with the joy Of elevated thoughts. . .

Problems of Immanence — Part 13

{ 34} But the world which is the dwelling of that something "far more deeply interfused" of which Wordsworth sings, does not consist exclusively of

Problems of Immanence — Part 13

the light of setting suns, And the round ocean, and the living air, And the blue sky. . .

Problems of Immanence — Part 13

--it contains also dismal, fever-breeding swamps, dreadful deserts, dreary wastes of eternal ice, plunged into darkness half the year; are we going simply to ignore these realities when we speak of the Divine indwelling in the world? And, once more, shall we assert this doctrine when we remember the cold cunning of the spider, or the delight in torture displayed by the domestic cat?

It depends, we answer, what we mean by "this doctrine"; if we construe immanence to signify "allness," we may as well admit first as last that there is no way of escape from the difficulties which these queries suggest. In that case it is not for us to pick and choose--to say that God is the beauty of the beautiful, but not the ugliness of the ugly; the compassion of the compassionate, but not the cruelty of the cruel: if He is _all_, He is _both_, and for that very reason is _neither_. That is the real inwardness of a conception of the Deity which represents Him, with Omar Khayyam, as One--